S&P faces US government suit over mortgage bond ratings
NEW YORK - Agence France-Presse
The Standard and Poor's building in New York is seen in this file photo taken August 3, 2012. REUTERS photoThe US government plans to sue Standard & Poor’s over its rating of mortgage bonds at the heart of the 2008 financial crisis, the agency said Monday, slamming the case as “entirely” groundless.
S&P said the Justice Department civil suit targets its ratings in 2007 of certain collateralized debt obligations, packages of mortgages that later plunged in value due to the US housing collapse, triggering the global crisis.
The credit risk agency promised a vigorous defense, saying the looming lawsuit would be “entirely without factual or legal merit.” A Justice Department spokeswoman declined to comment, but media reports said the suit, which is expected to be joined by state governments, could be filed later this week.
It would be the first US suit against a credit ratings agency. S&P, along with peers Moody’s and Fitch, has come in for heavy criticism for failing to unearth the problems with certain collateralized debt obligations.
The US complaint, as described by S&P, appears to allege that S&P’s high ratings on CDOs played a major role in the crisis because of the confidence they engendered in investors.
But S&P said that in 2007 and prior to that time, it had downgraded a number of residential mortgage-backed securities included in the CDOs ahead of other ratings agencies.
“With 20/20 hindsight, these strong actions proved insufficient -- but they demonstrate that the DoJ would be wrong in contending that S&P ratings were motivated by commercial considerations and not issued in good faith,” it said.
US prosecutors have questioned former S&P analysts on whether the firm ignored its own standards when rating the securities because of fees from investment banks, according to a report in the Wall Street Journal.
Up until last week, the Justice Department and S&P had held settlement talks. But the discussions ceased after the Justice Department said it would seek at least $1 billion to settle the case, according to the New York Times, which cited people who were briefed on the government’s plans.
S&P contends that it was far from alone in its failure to predict the scale of the collapse of the US housing market.
That crash wiped hundreds of billions of dollars in value from mortgage securities, leading to the government having to step in and rescue major banks which had invested in them.
Rather, S&P cited the congressional testimony of a former Securities and Exchange Commission chairman who said the SEC, the Federal Reserve and three other US agencies themselves did not predict the market collapse. “Regrettably, the breadth, depth and the effect of what ultimately occurred were greater than we -- and virtually everyone else -- predicted,” S&P said.
S&P is a unit of McGraw-Hill, whose shares fell 13.8 percent Monday after the news of the suit. Fellow ratings agency Moody’s was also lower, by 10.7 percent.
Moody’s did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
A Fitch spokesman said he is “unable to comment on the S&P matter as it does not involve us, other than to say we have no reason to believe Fitch is a target of any such action.”