US role in Egypt unclear
BRADLEY KLAPPERHaving pressed the new Egyptian president, US Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton on Sunday sought to mobilize what influence the United States still has with the army chief whose key role in post-Hosni Mubarak Egypt is splitting the country between those who see the military as a threat to democracy and those clinging to it as a guarantor of stability.
The United States sees it as a bit of both. Clinton’s demand to the military was simple: Work with Egypt’s new Islamist leaders on a full transition to civilian rule.
But with the US having already approved yet another massive delivery of military aid, it was unclear what leverage the Obama administration has as it seeks to stabilise Egypt and build a new relationship with America’s once ironclad Arab ally.
Clinton’s meeting with Field Marshal Hussein Tantawi in Cairo came with Egypt’s transformation from dictatorship to democracy in peril.
Tantawi’s council of generals is locked in a tense political standoff with the Muslim Brotherhood after curtailing the powers of its victorious President Mohammed Mursi on the eve of his inauguration last month and enforcing a court decision dissolving the Islamist-dominated parliament. Together the actions have created an atmosphere where no one is quite sure who is in control and where Egypt is headed.
Seventeen months after the street demonstrations that ousted Mubarak, the US is left without a friend and with little influence among a host of old and new political actors who can’t seem to chart a mutual path forward. Calling for compromise and consensus after her first ever meeting with Mursi, Clinton staked out a middle ground in the dispute. Yet the immediate effect of her exhortations was nothing.
For the Obama administration, the old prism supporting Egypt’s military leaders as bedrock allies shattered with Mubarak’s demise. It wants to safeguard US interests in the region, from counterterrorism cooperation to Arab-Israeli peace efforts, but its agenda remains on hold while the Arab world’s most populous nation remains mired in turmoil. The lack of clarity over who is going to prevail from Egypt’s political maneuvering is only adding to the paralysis.
Clinton, who earlier this year certified sufficient Egyptian action toward democracy for $1.3 billion in US military aid to go through, carried the same message to Tantawi as Mursi. Without taking a position in disputes over parliament or how to draft a new constitution, Clinton urged the long-time military chief to return the armed forces to a “purely national security role,” as she termed it.
Her criticism was muted, however. Clinton commended the military for defending lives during the February 2011 revolution against the former president and for the progress Egypt made under its interim leadership, which included free and fair elections. And she contrasted the approach with how Syria’s military is “murdering their own people,” while recognising that the Egyptian military authorities still needed to do more.
It was unclear if she adopted a tougher tone with Tantawi behind closed doors or what that might even yield from the generals, whose distrust of America is now almost as strong as that of the Brotherhood.
The US is in a difficult spot, eager to be seen as a champion of democracy and human rights after three decades of close cooperation with Mubarak despite his abysmal record in advancing either. This has involved some uncomfortable changes, including occasionally harsh criticism of America’s once faithful partners in the Egyptian military and words of support for Islamist parties far more sceptical of US motivations for Egypt and the region.
Foreign Minister Mohamed Amr said Mursi stressed in his meeting with the American secretary that he would respect all treaties Egypt has entered into, which includes the landmark 1979 peace accord with Israel.
According to Amr, the president spoke in favour of a comprehensive Israeli-Palestinian peace deal along the 1967 borders and with east Jerusalem as the capital of the future Palestine — a moderate Arab vision for a two-country solution that his party members have been often vague on in the past.
Clinton and Mursi also spoke about Egypt’s distressing economic outlook. Clinton promised that the US would make good on well over $1 billion dollars in debt relief, private investment capital and job creation funds that Washington has previously outlined.
*This article orginally appeared on Khaleej Times online.