TURKEY
• DIPLOMACY
Thursday, September 09 2010 10:54 GMT+2
Your time is 
 

Muslims, Christians pray together in Polonezköy

Font Size: Larger|Smaller
JUSTİNA SZEWCZYK
Muslims, Christians pray together in Polonezköy

Poles in and Turks greeted each other warmly as the priest at the small church in Polonezköy, a village on Istanbul’s Asian outskirts settled by Polish emigrants in the 19th century, invited worshippers to exchange the peace during the All Saints’ Day mass on Nov. 1.

Muslim Turks participating in a Christian ritual was “normal for Polonezköy,” an elderly inhabitant of the town said. The priest conducted the mass in both Polish and Turkish so that everyone could participate. After the mass, the congregants commemorated the deceased at a nearby cemetery with flowers while the priest blessed the gravestones with holy water, just as he would in Poland.

The cemetery reflects the story of Polonezköy. The majority of the oldest graves belong to Polish soldiers, combatants in many national uprisings during the 19th century. The Ottoman state was the only one in Europe that did not recognize Russian, Prussian and Austrian’s late-18th century partitions of Poland.

In 1841, Duke Adam Czartoryski sent emissary Michał Czajkowski from Paris to Istanbul to negotiate the establishment of a Polish colony there. One year later, Sultan Abdülmecid I granted Istanbul’s Polish mission the right to take land from the Lazarite Order and establish a semi-autonomous Polish settlement, Adampol, named after Czartoryski.

“Thank the Lord, who gave us this land where we can pray for Poland and talk about Poland in Polish – let’s pray and act righteously and God will return us to our Motherland,” Czajkowski, also known as Mehmet Sadık Paşa after he converted to Islam and served in the Ottoman army, said in a letter during the initial settlement period.

Speaking Polish in Poland was forbidden under Prussian and Russian rule, but Adampol was a safe haven for Polish patriots. Poles not only found refuge in the Sultan’s land, but also fought on the side of the Ottomans in the Crimean War (1853-56) against the Russians.

By the end of the 19th century approximately 150 Poles lived in the village. Even in 1918 after Poland finally re-gained its independence, the Poles in Adampol remained in Turkey. Today, there are about 750 inhabitants in Polonezköy, 90 of whom are of Polish origin.

“We are Turks with Polish origin,” said Antoni Dohoda, one of the elderly inhabitants. “I was a Turkish officer,” he said proudly. The Polish-Turkish friendship seen in Polonezköy is indeed amazing: The villagers said it was natural to see Polish and Turkish flags flying side-by-side or flowers from the gendarmerie at Czartoryski’s monument.

On one side of Adam Mickiewicz St., named for a famous Polish writer who died in Istanbul in 1855, there is both a Catholic church and a mosque just a few meters away from each other. “We go to weddings together, funerals and we carry coffins for each other when needed,” said Dohoda, somewhat surprised at the question about religious issues.

Dohoda said he was not worried about the loss of Polish culture and language. Though there is now much intermarriage in the community, he said this was a worldwide trend. Whatever the case, religious and cultural life in the community remains strong – mass is held every Saturday evening, after which Sister Arleta leads a number of children in religious study. Also, the children prepare a nativity play for the birth of Jesus every Christmas.

Recently, land from the graves of Adam Czartoryski and Michał Czajkowski were brought to Polonezköy and placed in symbolic graves in a ceremony attended by Polish President Lech Kaczyński. Indeed, the town often receives visits from Polish heads of state during their trips to Turkey, having hosted former presidents Lech Wałęsa and Aleksander Kwaśniewski in the past.

Polonezköy keeps ties not only with Poland, where children go every year for holidays, but also with similar Polish migrant communities in Romania. In October, Polonezköy welcomed 12 children and two teachers from Nowy Soloniec in Romania.

“We also want to establish connections with Polish towns in Georgia. The origins of these villages are the same – they were built by Polish patriots,” said Polonezköy Mayor Daniel Ohotski. These meetings with other Polish children motivate interest in Polish culture and help to maintain the language, he said.

Polonezköy is not just a heritage park for Polish culture, but also a beautiful destination for residents of Istanbul seeking a quiet place for a weekend getaway. Hotels and restaurants offering traditional Polish and Turkish food attract Istanbul clientele.

The fact that there is no public transportation connecting Polonezköy to Istanbul helps to maintain the peacefulness of the village. Moreover, Ohotski is not very enthusiastic about the idea of having a public bus – “That would bring too many people. It is good the way it is now,” he said.


 

20 Comments   Bookmark and Share  printer friendly PRINTER FRIENDLY

READER COMMENTS

Guest - eddi
2010-03-13 05:59:38
  All I can say is that the elderly of my village had no reason to lie. Like hundreds of other villages in Anatolia in that time they have experienced the most horrendous things witnessing how their parents, grandparents, siblings, children and friends were slaughtered by muslin Kurds and Turks. The people of my village wasn't at war. They were ordinary people living their lives when the decree went out from the ottoman government at the time to kill all Christians. They got help from the Kurds. This is evidence enough for me. Yes, some Armenians and other Christians joined the Russian forces but not in such an extent that it could be described as a full scale civil war that required the actions that was taken. Just the fact that the Nazis made "study trips" to Turkey to learn from the Turkish military how they operated when trying to eliminate the Christians in Anatolia (a few years before they themselves began to kill the Jews among others) is evidence enough. There are German documents stating this. Why would they go on these "study trips" if there was not a genocide to learn from? You tell me. And for all of you starring blindly at the events of 1915-16 as an isolated event, open your eyes further cause the massacres started in a "smaller" scale already around the 1830's. With other words, this was not just an act of self defense connected to the ongoing war with the Russians as the Turks say. Hate though is not the way. Were responsibility is taken, remorse is shown and an honest will of reconciliation from both sides exists, good things occur. But only then. In life, whether it concerns small sins or big ones, it's the one uncovering his sins, hence making them visible, and asking for forgiveness that can and will be forgiven. The one who's denying them and who is trying to hide them will only make the unrighteousness of his acts worse hence making the process of forgiving him more difficult.
 

Guest - BasilMacedon
2010-03-13 00:53:47
  Brian the "Irish", if you want to be fair then lets consider the following: If Armenians have to sit on the table with Turks to decide if "Armenian Genocide" was a genocide commited by Turks... then you should answer why AngloSaxons didnt give that chance to Germans? Yeap, if you want to be fair you should speak about the German right to sit together with US/Uk and Israel and discuss if the Germans have indeed commited a genocide in WW2 or not since Its all about discussion for you, then that discussion should apply to Germans too. Do you disagree?
 

Guest - Armen
2009-11-09 07:09:13
  Have you heard of Armenian Churches (as old as beginning of Christianity) considered as world heritage now in Eastern Turkey destroyed, vandalized or deliberately exploded by dynamite by Turkish military! Do you know where is ANI? A thousand years ago Ani was the capital of an Armenian kingdom that covered much of present day Armenia and eastern Turkey. Ani had a population of at least 100,000 and its wealth and renown was such that it was known as the "City of 1001 Churches". Built on a spectacular site - a plateau encircled by deep ravines - Ani's many churches, palaces, and fortifications were amongst the most technically and artistically advanced structures in the world at that period. Ani is now a ghost city, uninhabited for over three centuries and marooned inside a Turkish military zone on Turkey's border with modern Armenia. Ani's recent history has been one of continuous and always increasing destruction. Neglect, earthquakes, cultural cleansing, vandalism, quarrying, amateurish restorations and excavations - all these and more have taken a heavy toll on Ani's monuments. Yet still Ani survives. Enter VirtualANI for a tour of the ruins, plus an exploration of some of the medieval Armenian churches, monasteries, and castles that are located elsewhere within Turkey (in English or Turkish): http://www.virtualani.org/citymap.htm http://www.virtualani.org/citymap-turkish.htm
 

Guest - kostas
2009-11-08 18:57:48
  Historical research is made by free thinking historians. Why should it be made by a "commission" in the case of the Armenian Genocide? Every single historian is welocome to do research upon any subject and we, citizens of the world, should have our ears open to all sides. It looks really surrealistic to me. Personally, I m 100% convinced that the Jewish Holocaust really existed and no commission's results helped me in making my mind. The fact only that out of the 50.000 Thessaloniki Jews only 2.000 returned from Auschwitz is enough proof to me. The only 2 steps official Turkey should do are: 1. Open the Ottoman archives to all historians. 2. Decriminalize the acceptance of Armenian Genocide by Turkish citizens.
 

Guest - From Spain
2009-11-08 13:14:18
  I also think that Armenia should accept that history commission to probe that there was a "genocide". If not, they are telling the whole world that they are not sure about what they have been saying for a century, or even not telling all the truth. I also whant to thank David for that very interesting document from New York Times en 1914, although this is not the first time that I see documents tha really probe that massacres were not committed only by one side. Yes, I have seen lots of photos from armenians allegedly killed by turks, they are everywhere... But I also have seen lots of photos of hundred of turks killed by armenians, smiling next to shot children, or fields completely covered by dead bodies of turks (children, women...). This photos are not so easy to see and not so many people talk about them in forums or speechs, but they are there. I don´t say that armenians not died during the I WW, it´s obvios they did and I feel really sorry about them; but it´s obvious turks also died for thousands killed by armenians, and this is never said. It was a war, and it was 100 years ago. I think the problem is that armenians have not forgotten nor forgiven that turks got their dream of keeping united their homeland, while armenians didn´t achieve their dream of creating a "Great Armenia" in Eastern Anatolia. So I think it´s time both for turks and armenians to sit down and talk openly, and to look at the future. As a citizen from Spain and from Europe, I also find very cynical listen to european politicians telling to Turkey how they have to deal with minorities, while we spelled all jewish and muslims from Spain in 1492 and they refugied in the Ottoman Empire, or while muslims really have to find very hard for their rights in Europe. I suggest you, try to go to Granada and ask the muslim community there (which is very numerous now) how many decades did they have to wait and fight just to build a very small mosque in the city... I feel ashamed. We also can see similar examples in other countries like Germany or France, or with the muslims living in Greece...
 

Guest - Özür Diliyorum
2009-11-08 13:08:34
  1915’te Osmanlı Ermenileri’nin maruz kaldığı Büyük Felaket’e duyarsız kalınmasını, bunun inkar edilmesini vicdanım kabul etmiyor. Bu adaletsizliği reddediyor, kendi payıma Ermeni kardeşlerimin duygu ve acılarını paylaşıyor, onlardan özür diliyorum. My conscience does not accept the insensitivity showed to and the denial of the Great Catastrophe that the Ottoman Armenians were subjected to in 1915. I reject this injustice and for my share, I empathize with the feelings and pain of my Armenian brothers and sisters. I apologize to them.
 

Guest - David Coors
2009-11-08 02:51:43
  Look at the documents who massacred who: http://query.nytimes.com/mem/archive-free/pdf?_r=1&res=9B03E0DC1738E633A25750C1A9679D946596D6CF Turkish Armenians In Armed Revolt The New York Times Published: Novembver 13, 1914 Were Ready to Join Russian Invaders, Having Drilled and Collected Arms SEE DAY OF DELIVEREANCE Native Paper Says They are Prepared for Any Sacrifice - Refuse to Join Turkish Army. PETROGRAD, Nov. 12. - Reports reaching to Russian capital from the Turkish border attach increasing importance to the part the Armenians are playing in the Russo-Turkish war. In the several towns occupuied by the Russians the Armenian students have shown themselves ready to join the invading army, explaingin that they had prepared themsleves for the Russian approach by constant drilling and by gathering arms secretly. All along the line of march, according to these dispatches, the Armenian peasants are receiving the Russian troops with enthusiasm and giving provisions to them freely. An Armenian newspaper, referring to this crisis in the history of Armenia, publishes the following: "The long-anticipated day of deliverance for the Turkish Armenians is at hand, and the Armenians are prepared for any sacrifice made necessary by the performance of their manisfest duty." From this border country there have come to Petrograd further reports of armed conflicts arising from the refusal of Armenians to become Turkish conscripts and to surrender thier arms. It is now rumored that the important City of Van is now besieged by Armenian guerrila bands in great force. In Feitun the number of insurgents is said to exceed 20,000m and they are reported to have defeated all the Turkish troops sents against them, causing heavy losses to the Turks.
 

Guest - hayuhi
2009-11-07 22:26:43
  This is for Brian, " The Irishman"....there is something that gives me cause to think that the alleged Great Famine in Ireland, was not really a famine, and that over one million Irish did not emigrate to the United States as a result of that famine and the fact that England did not help them at all. The alleged non admittance of the catholics in the Irish parlimant at the time should also be open to full historical research.....yes Irish people should be grabbing this opportunity with both hands and feet......Brian the joke is on you! You have been "found out"!
 

Guest - Hey Umit
2009-11-07 20:01:26
  "I am a turk and if we implemented a genocide in 19th century, everybody can be sure that we will pay for its cost." This is the exact, well thought out, well -prepared lie that is most popular with Turks. Pay the cost? You're only Nobel Laureate in history feels unsafe in his home country because he agreed that the genocide was a reality. You're ready to pay the cost? An Armenian journalist was shot dead in broad-daylight because he agreed that the Genocide was a reality. The officers who arrested the suspect took pictures with him in front of the turkish flag not an hour after the murder. The man's body hadn't even gotten cold yet. And you're ready to pay the cost? You're government spends millions upon millions of $$$ a year to deny Genocide resolutions across the globe even going as far as blackmail (google Sibel Edmonds), and you're ready to pay the cost? Umit, you're not even pyscholigically prepared to TALK about it, never mind confessing and...wait for it...paying the cost. And yes, America and the EU are all to well aware of the veracity of the Armenian Genocide. Maybe you should look into some of the off the record remarks of American members of congress who voted against the Genocide bill, stating that while they have no doubt that a Genocide occured, they cannot recognize it for fear of alienating Turkey. Or the ADL (next to AIPAC, one of Turkeys strongest lobbying allies), who state basically the same thing. They however do it for the "safety" of Israel. And you, Umit, are ready to pay the cost. Whatever you're selling, you should talk to Brian. He look slike he might be a good customer.
 

Guest - Brian
2009-11-07 20:00:36
  Thanks VSM and Umit. I am just trying to be fair. And thanks too Armenian Survivor who almost thought he was an Irishman for a minute! :-) You are talkinge about Turkish agents, nationalist Turks etc, .....BUT...You have not made any point! And you have not answered the question either! Why will Armenia not agree to an independent investigation? We unbiased Irishmen can only think of one reason! No case for Turkey to answer! If there is a case, agree to the investigation. Get everything out in the open and close this festering wound.
 

Guest - Hey Timur
2009-11-07 19:46:10
  Out of curiosity? What exactly did you survive?
 

Guest - Hey Brian
2009-11-07 19:44:02
  You claim you're not biased, then go on to spew forth the Official Turkish Denialist Stance, basically point for point. By the way, you don't really believe that there is an equal amount of reputable scholars on both sides of the argument do you? If you do you should really consider stepping out of your shell. Justin McCarthy, Heath Lowry, and Bernard Lewis...all paid agents of the Turkish Governement. Brian, do you know what Article 301 of the Turkish Penal Code is? Are you familiar with the names Orhan Parmuk or Hrant Dink? If you are, do you truly believe that there is a climate of true and honest historical introspection within Turkish society? If you believe that there is, well, you'll believe just about anything.
 

Guest - umit
2009-11-07 16:09:26
  Hi Brian I agree with you Brian. I am a turk and if we implemented a genocide in 19th century, everybody can be sure that we will pay for its cost. . Just accept the investigation offer, its so easy They don't accept the offer because they are vilifiying. They know this too. Also America and other EU contries know reality. ..bye for know...umit
 

Guest - Irish Brian
2009-11-07 14:07:45
  Ooops... I am not 'Irish' nor Brian! I am the same 'Armenian Survivor' below! Did you get the message! Only a genuine nationalist Turk or an "alleged Turkish agent" uses 'alleged' word, and passionately repeats the same Turkish government bullshit propaganda! However, Turkey has no other choice! Turkey has to face its genocidal history. 94 years of Repudiation and Falsification of the facts and Turkish archives won't be usable in any court case! But, incriminates further the perpetrator of genocide!
 

Guest - timur
2009-11-07 13:44:41
  Armenian survivor - its getting boring now .. yawn yawn from another survivor
 

Guest - VSM
2009-11-07 13:03:04
  Thanks Brian! We'll all benfit from a more rational approach and interpretation of events, -which, as a generalization, unfortuntely is in short supply in this geography.
 

Guest - Brian
2009-11-07 11:52:25
  Dear Armenian survivor, I'm Irish and am not biased in either direction regarding the alleged genocide. Many scholars believe it is a fact but many other scholars disagree. But, there is something that gives me cause to think that this was not genocide, but part of a war. Why? Well, despite numerous offers from Turkey to establish a panel of international historians including Armenian and Turkish to study the issue and come to a mutual decision, Armenians have refused this offer. Why would Armenia do this? I can only think of one reason. That is, there is very little evidence to support the genocide theory and this will be evident from an investigation such as this. If you really believe this genocide is historical fact, Armenia should be grabbing this opportunity with both hands. But you don't. While Armenia preserves this stance of "NO investigation, just believe what we say", I will follow the natural justice in this world which is "Innocent until proven guilty" It is only natural to be aggrieved by loss of life and home, but Turks died too, as a result of Armenians helping the Russian invaders. There is a strict guideline as to what and what isn't genocide and I have my doubts that this was one. I could be wrong but why doesn't Armenia agree to find out?
 

Guest - Annabelle
2009-11-07 08:44:51
  I think this is a great story. It really shows how ordinary people with different ethnic backgrounds and religions can get on with living and loving with tolerance for one another's differences. It was so in Turkey when the Greeks were here, in other places also like Egypt, and Spain in the years before the reconquest of Spain by the Catholic Kings. Is it a mixture of fear and nationalism that disturbs this? From my perspective as an outsider, Islam seems to be a particularly tolerant religion in its everyday form. May it always continue so...
 

Guest - Armenian Survivor
2009-11-07 08:26:41
  This event reminds me Armenian genocide 1915-1921. It's ironical to face Turkish 2-face policies back in 19th and 20th centuries till today. In one hand Turkish Ottoman governments gave refuge to Jews and some smaller Christian groups such as Pols, but on other hand slaughtered millions of native Armenians, Pontic Greeks and Assyrians, appropriating victims' belongings, wealth and lands. How many Christian Armenian churches were burned down filled with ordinary Armenian women, children and elderly? How many Armenian cemeteries were desecrated or flattened? How many voices of prayers "for mercy" were silenced by Turkish mob and gendarmes? Nevertheless, be sure that even Polish refugees witnessed the slaughter.
 

Guest - Mark Rivers
2009-11-07 00:45:07
  I do not understand why the author says "Poles and Turks greeted each other .." To me they are all Turks, because they are all citizens of Turkiye. Turkiye's constitution says so. They should be called Polish Turks, or Turks of Polish descend, or Turks of Polish heritage. And the rest of the article should be corrected accordingly. A Turk does not have to be Moslem, Christian, Judaist, Budist etc necessarily. A Turk can also be a Atheist. The constitution says so, because of the freedom of religion, even though many people (including Europeans) do not think so. This is nothing short of stereotyping.
 

WRITE A COMMENT

Verification code
E-mail is required in case we need to communicate with you. It will not appear on the website and will never be used for any other purposes.
Comments policy: The Daily News seeks and supports freedom of expression and this commitment extends to our readers. Constraints include comments judged to be in violation of Turkish press law. We also moderate hate speech, libel and gratuitous insults.












Home | To Top | User Agreement and Privacy Policy | Rights and Permissions | Contact Us | Company | About News Room| RSS RSS Feed