LEADING NEWS SOURCE FOR TURKEY AND THE REGION

BURAK BEKDİL > Confusing Turkey

Print Page Send to friend »
I am tempted to blame my confusion on generous doses of Bai Jiu, the traditional Chinese liqueur. But sober reading of the news causes even more confusion, as I inevitably catch even more confusing details. The events that make one think “only in Turkey” would not leave you alone even on Mars.

Take America’s top military commander, Martin Dempsey, for instance. Last December, Gen. Dempsey said that “it was unclear the latest steps taken by EU leaders would be enough to hold the eurozone together.” For a second, I thought I was reading a statement from the Federal Reserve chairman, not a general. That was Fed Chairman Dempsey. Then in February Mr. Dempsey the secretary of state said that “intervention in Syria would be very difficult and it would be ‘premature’ to arm the besieged country’s opposition movement.” And most recently, Mr. Dempsey the secretary of defense said: “Of course we always have to provide military options, and they should be considered. But economic and diplomatic measures should first be used to push [Syrian President Bashar al-] Assad to make the right decision.”

Meanwhile, Gen. Dempsey’s Turkish counterpart, Chief of General Staff Gen. Necdet Ozel, reportedly told his hosts in Washington that “regarding Syria, every step to be taken is under the authority of the government.”

Have we not been taught that in democracies generals do not make political (or economic) statements? Does that comparative picture not make Turkey a better democracy than the United States? The lucky Gen. Dempsey could have been sent to jail on terrorism charges if he commanded the military of Turkey instead of the U.S.

Then, of course, there is Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoğlu. “It is not possible for us to bring democracy to Libya but refrain from bringing democracy to Syria.” Great logic. But then every sane mind would ask: “Is it possible that we can bring democracy to Libya and Syria but refrain from bringing democracy to Saudi Arabia and the Gulf countries?” Or is Mr Davutoglu’s “hey we are bringing democracy to you” mission limited to bringing democracy only to hostile regimes? Why deprive friendly nations of the virtues of democracy? Do the Saudis and the Qataris not deserve the freedom to vote?

At a safe distance of about 6,000 kilometers, I read with laughter Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s latest conspiracy theory that “abortion is a covert plan to erase our nation from the world stage.” In a second speech Mr. Erdoğan went so far as to hint that a “Jewish hand” is behind this plan. The prime minister is right.

Take China, for example. Decades ago China’s own leaders (I am not sure with which enemy countries they covertly plotted this conspiracy) launched a family planning policy that advocated delayed marriage and delayed child bearing, fewer and healthier births, and one child for one family. And now, see, as a result, China has been erased from the world stage. If only Deng Xiaoping had heard about Mr. Erdoğan’s “three or five children per family” policy. Perhaps then China could have been the world’s second largest economy today.

Yes, size does matter. That’s why poor Muslim immigrants risk their lives to flee to live a decent life in the grossly populous Pakistan instead of tiny Switzerland. That’s why populous Indonesia tops the UN human development index, and not the mini-nations of Norway and Luxembourg. And, of course, that’s why macro-state Turkey is an EU member, and micro-states like Cyprus and Malta are not.

And there is the Uludere incident, in which Turkish fighter jets erroneously bombed and killed 34 Kurdish smugglers on Dec. 28. Mr. Erdoğan has confusingly likened the incident to abortion. If we recall that he had earlier said “abortion was murder,” we can safely conclude that the prime minister thinks that “the Uludere incident was murder.” But then, even more confusingly, Mr. Erdoğan thinks that “regarding Uludere there is nothing to apologize for.” So, murder does not require even an apology? Because the murdered people were Kurds? Because the murderers belong to a now-friendly institution, not an enemy one?

It’s all so confusing.

June/01/2012

PRINTER FRIENDLY Send to friend »

READER COMMENTS

Notice on comments

american american

6/3/2012 4:55:28 PM

oh jj, you are too smart for me. i must admit it. my mother is greek, my father an armenian, and i am a kurdish jew. that still doesn't lessen america's ability to only kill 'enemy combatants' with drone attacks. come to think of it, about that wedding 'massacre', why were a group of people gathering in a war zone? unfortunate accident, but just a mistake...

Mork and Mindy Simpson

6/2/2012 11:43:40 AM

@ismail So what about the other 40000+ are all of these Kurdish problems a result of the PKK only? I don't think so. I am proud to be TURKISH. But I am not blind. All countries have a terrible record when dealing with terrorists including America, Turkey,Spain, England and Israel to name but a few. There is a wonderful English Expression "People who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones"

moshe pipick

6/2/2012 2:24:26 AM

From the news, the world is getting the impression that Turkey is turning into an islamic regime like Iran. The way kangaroo court indictments read and now even pianist cannot recite a poem without facing jail time. Soon the journalists will be self exiled, maybe to China..

ismail demir

6/1/2012 8:51:56 PM

@simpson in terms of anti teror policy american human right record is worse than Turkey.In other issues america probably better human right record(that is irrelevant here because we discuss uludere event). majority of EHCR violation of Turkey simple issues as long court procedures not killing people in wedding

JJ Ahf

6/1/2012 7:34:42 PM

american american don't try hard. An true American would know how it is to fight against terrorism and how it is to protect the borders from illegal immigration and trade. Do you really want to talk about the US wedding massacre in Iraq and the censorship regarding the Iraq war in the USA. Come on feel free and confess you're of kurdish armenian or greek descent.

Mork and Mindy Simpson

6/1/2012 5:40:40 PM

@ismail Did you just say that America has worse human rights than Turkey? OKKKKKKKKayyyyyyyyyy. What ever floats your boat. Ah of course it is America that has more than 15000 and climbing violations of individual human rights before the ECHR each year. Thanks for making me aware of the obvious spelling mistake TURKEY should be read as AMERICA in those reports. Got it, it won't happen again

OZman Cometh

6/1/2012 5:15:34 PM

American by name .. the U.S. are the masters of supporting democracy selectively I.e. when it suits! Turkey starting game and is smart enought to know when to pick battles. S.A et al can wait for now at least they are not doing any mass killings. It is normal that as a nation prospers, birth rates decline so Recep is on the ball here. Uludere is unfortunate and needs to be investigated. BB I am currently touring Israel at the mo, thought you would have stayed to form and thrown me a bone. :/

Turk down under

6/1/2012 4:13:08 PM

I'm confused!

ismail demir

6/1/2012 4:11:37 PM

Minimum 1 civilian dead for 3 militans for afghanistan, majority of observes put higher figures, that is why NATO or america have not give any number officially.

mara mcglothin

6/1/2012 3:58:51 PM

Spot on AMERICAN!!!
< >

MOST POPULAR

AcerPro S.I.P.A HTML & CSS Agency