LEADING NEWS SOURCE FOR TURKEY AND THE REGION

EMRE DELİVELİ > Are foreign languages useless?

Print Page Send to friend »
Although he is being considered for the World Bank presidency, a very diplomatic position, economist Lawrence Summers never ceases to amaze me in his capacity to offend billions in a sentence or two.

After outraging half of the world by suggesting that the under-representation of women in science and engineering could be due to a “different availability of aptitude at the high end,” Summers offended almost the entire globe this time by stating that Americans don’t need to learn a foreign language since the rest of the world would soon be fluent in English anyway.

Since I, as a native Turkish speaker, am writing this column for a daily published in Turkey in English, I would be fighting a lost battle if I tried to disagree with Summers. It would not make much of a difference if I argued that God thought a single language was not a good idea either. He confused the language of the people of Babel, causing them to speak different languages so that they would not understand each other, but could He really be wiser than Larry Summers?



Joking aside, there is no simple answer to the question, “how many languages do we need?” Economists Victor Ginsburgh, a Belgian of Austrian origin whose mother tongue is Swahili, and Shlomo Weber, a Canadian citizen who is a native Russian speaker, try to offer some answers in a great book I finished in one read on Feb. 10.

One of their arguments is that language is an essential expression of culture. Just read how the Duke of Norfolk, in Shakespeare’s Richard II, despairs at the impending inability to express himself in his native language upon learning of his banishment to Venice. On the other hand, linguistic relativity holds that culture is shaped by one’s tongue.

Yale economist Keith Chen shows exactly that. In a very recent working paper, he demonstrates that speakers of languages that grammatically distinguish between present and future events take fewer future-oriented actions: They save less, hold less retirement wealth, smoke more, are more likely to be obese and suffer worse long-run health. By the way, Turkish is such a language.

These arguments highlight the importance of one’s native tongue, but they don’t disprove Summers - neither should they undermine the importance of learning English. Compared to its peers, Turkey ranks at the bottom in English proficiency indices. Economist Atilla Yeşilada was arguing, at a seminar on Feb. 9, that this “English deficit” is a major bottleneck on productivity.

One of the most interesting parts of Paul Theroux’s “The Great Railway Bazaar” is his chat with Yaşar Kemal on Sept. 25, 1973 - I know the date because Kemal sees Pablo Neruda’s death in the paper. The Turkish novelist tells Theroux that he doesn’t speak English or any other “barbarian languages.” He doesn’t need to. He can write in Turkish, and his work will be translated into 50 different languages. But young Turks are not that lucky. They need to learn English to be more hirable.

As for me, I will happily write my columns in English, but I am glad I can enjoy “İnce Memed” and “Las Alturas de Macchu Picchu” in their beautiful original versions, which cannot be captured by any translation.

February/13/2012

PRINTER FRIENDLY Send to friend »

READER COMMENTS

Notice on comments

sam stevens

2/14/2012 11:51:58 AM

English is the best language in the world. It is rich, with a vast vocabulary.On top of which there is the manner & subtlety in which some of that vocabulary is spoken,but it is not enough to 'know' a language,the speaker has to know the nuance too.

two sides to every coin

2/13/2012 7:45:01 PM

Well written article.

Kevin Snapp

2/13/2012 7:40:07 PM

Interesting -- is there a study of personality/attitudinal differences between those who know one or more foreign languages and those who don't, within and across cultures? Are monolingual Turks as "provincial" as Americans?

Red Tail

2/13/2012 11:39:27 AM

Maybe it will change in the future, but today no one can deny that English is a world language in business, science, entertainment, culture etc. Of course it would be nice to be able to read literature in original language, but to reach such a level.

Selda Yolar

2/13/2012 10:28:53 AM

English is my native tongue. I use what I know in Turkish many times to express my feelings or request...it seems that Turkish explains it much better than any English words I could use. Also Turkish has beautiful words for all occasions.

Emre Deliveli

2/13/2012 10:13:28 AM

@DKI: Thnx,I studied in Robert College,the American high school in Istanbul,but then lived in the States for over a decade.I also read a lot.Of course,I am more careful with the columns than my everyday writing&I do have an excellent editor as well:)

dogan kemal ileri

2/13/2012 3:00:29 AM

English is a world language and all of us Turks must try to be proficient as much as our aptitude allows and I must say we are all tryers in Turkiye at least.By the way Emre your command of English is excellent where did you learn it?
< >

MOST POPULAR

AcerPro S.I.P.A HTML & CSS Agency