TURKEY
• DIPLOMACY
Monday, September 06 2010 05:17 GMT+2
Your time is 
 

No partnership deal with Sweden after 'genocide' vote

Font Size: Larger|Smaller
FULYA ÖZERKAN
Following the passage of a ‘genocide' resolution by a US House committee, the Swedish legislature adopts a similar measure, drawing a strong response from Turkey and the canceling of PM Erdoğan's visit to Stockholm. Another casualty of the vote is Turkey's refusal to sign a strategic-partnership deal with Sweden
Swedish Ambassador to Turkey Christer Asp. AA photo

Swedish Ambassador to Turkey Christer Asp. AA photo

The passing of a resolution in the Swedish parliament labeling the 1915 killings of Armenians by Ottoman forces as “genocide” has prevented Sweden from signing a strategic-partnership deal with Turkey.

The vote, following the adoption of a similar measure by a U.S. House committee, drew a sharp response from Ankara, which swiftly recalled its ambassador to Stockholm in a show of protest.

The Swedish envoy to Ankara was summoned to the Foreign Ministry in response to the vote, which the Turkish government considers a setback in Turkish-Swedish relations. Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan meanwhile declared that he has canceled a scheduled trip to Sweden.

Erdoğan and the prime minister of Sweden were scheduled to sign an agreement in Stockholm this week under which the two countries planned to hold annual meetings on every level in the fields of politics, business and culture.

“We did hope to welcome Prime Minister Erdoğan to Sweden in order to set up a strategic partnership similar to what Turkey has with Italy and Spain,” Swedish Ambassador to Turkey Christer Asp told the Hürriyet Daily News & Economic Review in an interview.

The top diplomat originally planned to go to Stockholm over the weekend in preparation for the Turkish prime minister’s visit but had to cancel the trip after the vote.

“We attach great importance to our relations with Turkey. But, of course, now see what happened, and Mr. Erdoğan canceled his trip. That is another negative fallout,” Asp said, adding that they would continue to work on establishing relations.

The Swedish parliament was not unanimous in its vote, Asp said.

“The opposition side, with the support of parliamentarians from the governing side, managed to carry the resolution. Every year it has been rejected,” he said. “This year, when the issue first came up in the parliament’s foreign-relations committee, it was also rejected, but the opposition side obviously managed to convince some parliamentarians to jump ship at the last moment. That’s why it happened.”

Swedish gov’t policy ‘unchanged’

Sweden’s center-right coalition government has distanced itself from the resolution, which passed by a 131-130 vote. Foreign Minister Carl Bildt said Friday that he deplored the vote and assured it would not have an immediate consequence on the government’s policy toward Turkey.

Asp, who explained his government’s position to Turkish Foreign Ministry officials, said: “I underlined that this is the decision by the Swedish parliament. It is not a legally binding decision on the government.”

“According to Swedish constitutional rules, it is up to the government whether to transform the decision into government policy or not,” he added.

According to the top diplomat, the Swedish government believes history should not be politicized and backs the historical commission that has been suggested and agreed upon in the Turkish-Armenian protocols. This position, he said, remains unchanged.

Threat is still there

The resolution is in the form of a recommendation to the government and cannot become a law, Asp explained.

“It cannot be a law because it is in the form of a non-binding, non-legal proposal. It does not have any legal implications,” he said. “According to our constitution, in a case like this, it is entirely up to the government to decide whether it wants to take this proposal up or not. It stays there as far as Sweden is concerned.”

However, the possibility of the resolution turning into a law in fact remains because a different government may legally adopt the measure after the September elections in Sweden. The three opposition parties have already announced they would make it government policy if they came to power.

Swedish gov’t, parliament ‘back EU bid’

Saying he regarded the resolution as a “clear setback to bilateral relations,” Asp made it clear the development would not change Swedish support for Turkey’s European Union process. Sweden is one of the strongest advocates of the country’s EU bid and even challenged France when it was holding the bloc’s term presidency.

“On the EU process, this will change nothing. Even representatives of parties voting for the resolution have said this has nothing to do with the continuous support in the parliament for Turkey’s EU accession,” said the ambassador.

“The vote should be separated from the EU question. There will still be a very strong support from the Swedish government and the majority in the parliament,” he added. “There is strong support from among all the political parties for Turkish membership in the EU. That will not be affected.”

Impact on Turkey-Armenia normalization

The resolution passed in the Swedish legislature follows similar ones in France, Russia, Greece, Germany, Belgium and Canada. But the votes in the U.S. and Sweden come at a time when Turkey and Armenia are making efforts to normalize their ties.

“I certainly think this is not helpful for the normalization process between Turkey and Armenia,” said Asp. “I believe that we should concentrate our efforts on supporting this process.”


 

21 Comments   Bookmark and Share  printer friendly PRINTER FRIENDLY

READER COMMENTS

Guest - peace
2010-03-16 17:23:53
  Guest - Applekey - excellent comment and remarks. Simply, in democracy country, no one can be condamned up the moment the judgement. Swedih governement can't use qualified as the Genocide. Swedish parliament has no right, it is against the democracy value.
 

Guest - Applekey
2010-03-16 13:39:21
  “There is no crime without evidence. A genocide cannot be written about in the absence of factual proof.” book, “The Armenians.”The Armenians.” A.Henry R. Huttenbach, history professor who appears to support the Armenian viewpoint exclusively, as do… curiously… nearly all so-called “genocide scholars”; The Genocide Forum, 1996, No.9 t We must not confuse dissent with disloyalty. We must remember always that accusation is not proof and that conviction depends upon evidence and due process of law. We … are not descended from fearful men— not from men who feared to write, to speak, to associate and to defend causes that were, for the moment, unpopular. In what may be applied to the wide and mindless acceptance of the “Armenian Genocide,” this great thinker also said (“This I Believe,” 1951): “I have no problem with any religion as long as it remains about belief rather than absolute certainty. Belief is compatible with respect and tolerance for other beliefs. Certainty is an arrogance that leads to intolerance, disrespect and, all too often, terror and war.”
 

Guest - Rene
2010-03-16 00:48:17
  Turkey is always right - at least that is what the Turks think. It is just getting boring this issue of 100 years ago that is agitating Turkey (stupid) and which every time is popped up by Armenians abroad (stupid). When do the Turks and Armenians finally realize it is time to cooperate and step over this historical issue?
 

Guest - Erdur
2010-03-15 16:18:29
  @Sam. I did not understand what the slave issue had to do with the topic. But, what you have to realize is that we are living in a global world which is a like a spider webb with all sorts of contacts and interdependencies and people are moving around the world (just look att the millions of millions of Turks who have left Turkey to live in Europe). So your call for freedom is simply not relevant any longer. In the past when people were living on what they produced on their farm, then they were independent. But today everybody is dependent on each other and you reach your goals by COOPERATING with others.
 

Guest - sam
2010-03-15 13:59:25
  Erdur + Co ... firstly I would like to think I can (and Turkey) determine my own future and not be told what to do and when to do it. I am not a black African slave brought to pick cotton, get whipped for a ration of food !!! Being Independent and FREE its better than living with lies that are forced upon you by either the EU, Armenians or the US ... FREEDOM is the key word !
 

Guest - Adam
2010-03-15 13:47:45
  The evidence for the genocide is overwhelming. Apart from the holocaust, it is the most documented and researched. The formost independant worldwide body for genocide studies, the International Association of Genocide Schollars, overwhemlingly accepts that genocide took place. As for the role of Europeans and crimes against humanity, I agree that many European nations and the USA have committed horrible crimes and these should be investigated but this does not preclude recognition of the Armenian genocide by all, including Turkey. The argument against recognition because of other peoples wrong-doings is a silly one. The Ottoman Empire, like most other empires (British, Spanish, Dutch etc) committed many crimes. The difference is that in all other European countries people are free to debate and challenge and openly aknowledge these wrong doings. This, unfortunately does not apply in Turkey. Why is that?
 

Guest - Mikael from Sweden
2010-03-15 12:39:07
  @ J Benin (2010-03-15 10:29:06) "Sweden with its former forced sterilisation program intended to finish off the Roma and Saami people". What you are writing is not fully correct. The goal was not to "finish of the Roma and the Sami". In fact most cases were due to mental illnesses which the Government at that time did not want to pass on to future generations. Never the less such act can of course not be justified and it was down right wrong. It is something we read about in school and occassionaly you can also see documentaries on (state financed) TV. Further, there was a commision set up, which decided that 1600 of the victims should be compensated by the state for the suffering caused them. But of course, the entire Sweden recognizes that it was wrong, and it is now trying to handle it to avoid such errors in the future and have at least to some extent compensated the victim. And I am glad at least that the state tries to correct this misstake even if it of course would have been better if it never happened.
 

Guest - Erdur
2010-03-15 12:19:05
  I can not see how isolating our selves from the rest of the world can bring anything good to the regular Turkish citizen. Less export and less foreign influence and less foreign products to buy (back to Anadol cars and köfte every day?) and less foreign direct investment and less foreign companies established in Turkey (all university graduates want to work for foreign firms). So what is the point hurting our selves and to loose the support from one of the worlds most respectable countries which has also supported our EU application?
 

Guest - J Benin
2010-03-15 10:29:06
  So many terrible events committed by Europe and America in the 20th century are left to the historians - the Dutch massacres in Indonesia, the French killings in Algeria, French and US support to evil dictators in South America and Africa. But the victims of these powers have no strong lobbies. Don't the Vietnamese deserve an apology from Obama? How long before the sons and daughters of the Western cultural genocide in Africa, the slave trade, are compensated for the millions of their ancestors who died in slave labour in the Americas? Can we cherry pick genocides for short-term political victories or do all victims of history deserve the same empathy? Yes, Turkey should reflect on its history, but so should all nations - incl. Sweden with its former forced sterilisation program intended to finish off the Roma and Saami people, the Armenian killing of Azeri etc. History must be looked upon objectively and objective conclusions drawn.
 

Guest - mok10501
2010-03-15 07:23:25
  The message is very clear to me, "DON'T OPEN THE BORDERS WITH ARMENIA, KEEP TÜRKİYE CLEAR OFF UNDOCUMENTED ARMENIANS".
 

Guest - MARK
2010-03-15 01:42:50
  This clearly looks like a case of the rest of the world is wrong but Turkey is right.
 

Guest - Nshan
2010-03-14 23:15:10
  @Ertan Gursel. “If there is a little respect to Turkey such resolutions should have never brought to parliaments“. Don’t expect someone to respect you if you don’t respect yourself.
 

Guest - Kardes
2010-03-14 20:23:40
  This is for duyum in, mostly, his own words: I CONDEMN all Turkish people who deny the facts about the Armenian genocide, and who say they are based ENTIRELY on the HEARSAY 'evidence', the CIRCUMSTANTIAL 'evidence', the FORGED 'evidence' and the BLATANT PROPAGANDA of the Armenian Diaspora. The politicians who have denied these facts OBVIOUSLY have done so based on misguided ideological reasons and/or personal political gain. In doing so, they do a GREAT INJUSTICE to the honour and integrity of their own people and government. Now my words: Why do the Turks always make THEMSELVES the victims? Admit the wrongs of your past and move on! Do you REALLY believe you are such a clean culture that, above ALL others, you have not murdered hundreds of thousands of your enemies during war? You were not the first to commit genocide, and, sadly, you will not be the last. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 

Guest - Orhan
2010-03-14 19:58:55
  It's time for Turkiye to stop hiding its head in the sand and face its past. Bravo Sweden for honoring the souls of the massacred Armenians.
 

Guest - CARNAN
2010-03-14 19:52:09
  I do not still understand how one country decide the genocide bill without consulting the international or national historians and experts just raise hand then yes We accept that Turkey did sth Bad.I do not want to say that word because it is not related to Turkey and Turkish History.It is so nonsence also no one proof inside...
 

Guest - M&M
2010-03-14 18:51:46
  I don't understand why Turkiye should open their border to Armenia or even bother to have normalization with them. They have been commiting all these crimes against the Turks, Azerbeycanis and now through out the nations with their lies and briberies, holding the nations and threatening the hisorians and politicians if they don't side with them. It's high time to stop these false allegations against Turkiye. Please Turkish government open your archives, set up a time and place, prove once and for all how Armenians have lied and are still doing it, they can do this with Armenia to be present or not. They have to be stopped, the nations of the world have more important issues to worry about and attend to.
 

Guest - James
2010-03-14 18:48:20
  More puffery from the Turkish side. Just as relations between Turkey and other European states who adopted similar resoultions affirming the Armenian Genocide have flurished afterwords, so will relations between Sweden and Turkiye.
 

Guest - ERTAN GURSEL
2010-03-14 18:13:32
  Turkey have a lot enemies that are trying to disturb peaceful life in Turkey. Behind of all these resolutions are the enemies of Turkey. If there is a little respect to Turkey such resolutions should have never brought to parliaments.
 

Guest - duyum
2010-03-14 18:12:37
  I CONDEMN the US House committee,and the Swedish legislature, for passing their respective resolutions, based ENTIRELY on the HEARSAY 'evidence', the CIRCUMSTANTIAL 'evidence', the FORGED 'evidence' and the BLATANT PROPAGANDA of the Armenian Diaspora. The politicians who voted in favour of the motions, OBVIOUSLY did so based on misguided ideological reasons and/or personal political gain. In doing so, they did a GREAT INJUSTICE to the honour and integrity of their own people and governments.
 

Guest - ERTAN GURSEL
2010-03-14 18:12:11
  Turkey have a lot enemies that are trying to disturb peaceful life in Turkey. Behind of all these resolutions are the enemies of Turkey. If there is a little respect to Turkey such resolutions should have never brought to parliaments.
 

Guest - Murat
2010-03-14 17:53:29
  Dumb, dumb and dumber....
 

WRITE A COMMENT

Verification code
E-mail is required in case we need to communicate with you. It will not appear on the website and will never be used for any other purposes.
Comments policy: The Daily News seeks and supports freedom of expression and this commitment extends to our readers. Constraints include comments judged to be in violation of Turkish press law. We also moderate hate speech, libel and gratuitous insults.












Home | To Top | User Agreement and Privacy Policy | Rights and Permissions | Contact Us | Company | About News Room| RSS RSS Feed