CULTURE
Thursday, September 09 2010 10:18 GMT+2
Your time is 
 

Fatih Akın boycotts Swiss over minarets

Font Size: Larger|Smaller
Fatih Akın (r) with actor Adam Bousdoukos (l) promoting their new film at the Lübeck Film Festival. AA photo

Fatih Akın (r) with actor Adam Bousdoukos (l) promoting their new film at the Lübeck Film Festival. AA photo

Prominent Turkish-German director Fatih Akın said Thursday he would not bring his new film to Switzerland in protest against the referendum vote that banned the construction of minarets in the country.

"This referendum conflicts with my understanding of humanism, tolerance and the belief that harmonious co-existence of peoples of differing backgrounds, races and religions must be possible," Akın said in an open letter.

"As a child of Muslim parents who do not see minarets as symbols of political Islam but rather simply the complete architecture of their houses of worship, I feel personally affected by the referendum. That is why I refuse to travel to Switzerland."

Akın was to present his new comedy "Soul Kitchen," which won the Special Jury Prize in September at the Venice Film Festival on Dec.16 in Zurich. The film is a light-hearted look at the multicultural mix in Akın's hometown Hamburg.

Akın is one of German-speaking world's hottest filmmakers, winning a screenwriting award for his drama "The Edge of Heaven" in 2007 at the Cannes Film Festival and the Golden Bear top prize in Berlin in 2004 for "Head-On."

The Swiss vote Sunday saw more than 57 percent back a proposition by a right-wing party for a constitutional ban on the construction of new minarets, overriding opposition from the government and most Swiss political parties.

The outcome inflamed tempers throughout the Muslim world.


 

23 Comments   Bookmark and Share  printer friendly PRINTER FRIENDLY

READER COMMENTS

Guest - mok10501
2010-05-08 08:24:42
  My hat is off for Mr. Akın. This is very good. Even if you are an atheist, you should still be applauding Akın's position on Switzerland's nonsensical ban on minarets. This is not just being religiously motivated move or symbolism but an issue which is a violation of universal rights of UN. Turkey should be proud of having one of his sons reached to this level and displaying this qualities.
 

Guest - Vagabundo
2009-12-08 00:41:24
  Yes indeed Demir, someone has problems understanding what people are saying. It did occur to me that there might be at least one person out there (There's always one!) who would come to the conclusion that it's my belief that the dastardly Fatih Akin would like nothing better than to smother the entire continent in minarets. You've smoked me out good and proper there Demir, well done.
 

Guest - Demir
2009-12-07 14:49:01
  @Vagabundo: Seems like someone's got problems with grasping reality and understanding what people are saying! When did Akin say that he wants minarets to be built everywhere. As for his boycott of Switzerland i say good on him, I will boycott all the Swiss exports and I will encourage other fair minded people to do so too!
 

Guest - Secular Canadian
2009-12-07 12:05:11
  Fatih Akin certainly has the right to express his views and opinions regarding the minaret ban; however, he would possess more credibility if he also acknowledged the persecution of Christian and other minorities in many muslim countries, such as Saudi Arabia, Iran and Pakistan.
 

Guest - Vagabundo
2009-12-07 02:44:03
  What a hero! Ya, it's funny, he just looks the type that if he were Turkish born and bred he wouldn't know a mosque from a hairdressers or, more likely he'd be one of those spouting from a bar stool somewhere about 'creeping Islamization'. Plant him in the middle of Europe though and he wants to build minarets everywhere!
 

Guest - 7 Hills
2009-12-05 12:53:51
  Who cares about a 2nd rate director and his latest silly film. I am sure the Swiss are not concerned. Why waste space in a newspaper or online to print such nonsense? Get a life!!
 

Guest - Boredd
2009-12-05 06:34:27
  Fatih who?? Big deal...
 

Guest - Swiss
2009-12-05 00:55:14
  Just keep making great movies and stop talking silly.
 

Guest - john horne
2009-12-04 22:43:55
  yes make sure it is in accordance with turkish law unlike the rest of Europe .that can publish what it want,s when it wan,t and not land in jail
 

Guest - YABANCHİıSTANBUL
2009-12-04 22:39:35
  Fatih must first learn what Humanism and Secularism means. Looks like his Sunni Turkish heritage is more important than humanism. And he is world famous in Turkey...but pushed with this statement himself in the corner. Hope he remembers Fashbinder, and Wenders is probably one million light years away from his artistic developments.
 

Guest - Mr Goksel Doganay
2009-12-04 22:16:27
  Some comments by bloggers on this article have been petty and lame. This article is not about the treatment of minorities in Muslims countries but rather the minaret ban. It has provoked a big response from Muslims because Swiss themselves have tried to potray their homeland as tolerant to other religions and also set themselves a high standard. If banning construction of minarets is used as a tool to highlight abuses in Muslim countries this is a disgraceful act. So the Swiss can mistreat its citizens because minorities get mistreated badly in Muslim countries. By this logic the Blacks can be mistreated in USA, South Africa and so on. I think some of the comments expressed here is disgraceful and basically it legitimizes abuse of minorities. These arguments are flawed and basically people who have a hatred of Muslims are coming out of the woodwork. Comparing this ban to countries like Iran, Somalia, Sudan, Pakistan is very disgraceful. These people do not care about how these countries treat Christians in these countries. If so why don't you not buy oil. Look at past record. Eastern Christians were used as pawns to invade Muslim countries. I would have more respect for these people to say I don't like Islam or Muslims rather than hiding behind shady arguments. I ask those people to actually show some courage write those words "I do not like Islam or Muslims" rather than making up crap. For the record in non-Muslim countries minarets are not used to call prays.
 

Guest - Sammy
2009-12-04 22:07:49
  @ REB, MAHMUT, JEN & GRZEGORZ - Congratulations on failing to "get it". The point here is that Swizterland claims to be an enlightened liberal democracy that upholds human rights and espouses "multi-culturalism". What a load of rubbish. It's the brazen and unabashed hypocrisy embraced by the Swiss (and the EU) that's the issue. While you may be blind to it, we are not.
 

Guest - AtheistTurk
2009-12-04 20:46:29
  Oh bloody hell, what an overreaction. Pathetic. Like others have said, he should boycott Saudi Arabia, Iran, Pakistan, China, USA, India, UAE, and TURKEY etc for all infringing on human rights.
 

Guest - Vural Korkmaz
2009-12-04 20:42:35
  Turkiye does not a full freedom of religion. You do not see one single person of non-Moslem religions in military and/or posts. A military officer (commissioned or non-commissioned) converts to a non-Moslem religion is fired immediately. No non-Moslem houses of worships is allowed to be built in Turkiye. That is not real democracy and/or freedom of religion. So, where the hell Turkishs goverment finds its confidence to critize other countries on religious matters!!!
 

Guest - J Benin
2009-12-04 20:26:22
  Very well put, Fatih Akin. The minaret is being turned into a negative symbol through this referendum. None of the existing Swiss minarets were used for calling to prayer. This could still be forbidden while allowing the construction of the minarets. It is clear that the Swiss extremist party was just looking for an issue that is not directly racist but causes division in Swiss society. Wish the Swiss people had remembered the "Jew Gold" scandal that also gave the country a bad reputation - not to mention the Swiss Red Cross' pro-nazi attitude during WW2. Time for the Swiss to learn from history. Maybe UN should really leave Geneve.
 

Guest - donha
2009-12-04 19:56:15
  Is he going to boycott those countries who have laws that flagrantly conflict with his understanding of humanism, tolerance and the belief that harmonious co-existence of peoples of differing backgrounds, races and religions? You know, places like Egypt, Saudi, Yemen, Indonesia, Pakistan, Libya, Iran, and yes Turkey too. If he does not then he is a hypocrite.
 

Guest - 7Hills
2009-12-04 19:04:34
  Who cares about a 2nd rate film director and his silly films? Why are people so upset about minarets being banned? The mosques are not banned. The religion is not banned.. only the minarets. People, get a life. Switzerland does not need him, or his "film".
 

Guest - Humanist
2009-12-04 18:04:08
  We love you Fatih Akin. You are a true humanist.
 

Guest - Evren
2009-12-04 17:43:49
  Minority rights should never be subject to majority vote in true democracy. Also comparing authoritarian countries (such as Pakistan,Suudi Arabia,Somali) with democratic country is nonsense and lame.
 

Guest - Grzegorz
2009-12-04 16:41:37
  It is about building minarets not mosques. Imagine for somebody when in early morning somebody is calling out from minaret and wake you up everyday. You did not get used to. Now, I build a church (if Turkish government allows me) with belfry and at certain hours bells will sound loudly. You did not get used to What would you say? Church? Maybe, but 99% no. Belfry? Hell no! Am I right?
 

Guest - Jen L. Jones
2009-12-04 15:39:48
  Akin has his work cut out from him in defending his vision of "humanism and tolerance." He can start with boycotting Pakistan (bombings of mosques, acid mutilation of women, "honour" killings, child marriage); and then he can add Saudi Arabia (banning of churches -- not just the spires atop them, cloistering of women, beheadings, floggings);then he can tackle Somalia (a hell-hole of stonings, floggings, summary justice); and then there's Iran with it's brutal repression of dissent --and on and on. Yes, Akin will be busy indeed.
 

Guest - Mahmut
2009-12-04 15:15:52
  I am pretty sure the Swiss will survive this tragedy quite well. And I am even more sure that - if he is consistent - he will not feel able to travel to a good many countries anymore... (how about Turkey, Egypt, Saudi, Indonesia, Pakistan, Libya, France, Denmark, USA, Iran ...?) Let him stay at home if he likes, he is a free man after all.
 

Guest - Reb
2009-12-04 15:01:33
  Senseless!!!.. Fatih Akın should first boycott Saudis for not allowing even a simple book of a Bible enter their country and he should boycott his own Turkey for many reasons.
 

WRITE A COMMENT

Verification code
E-mail is required in case we need to communicate with you. It will not appear on the website and will never be used for any other purposes.
Comments policy: The Daily News seeks and supports freedom of expression and this commitment extends to our readers. Constraints include comments judged to be in violation of Turkish press law. We also moderate hate speech, libel and gratuitous insults.












Home | To Top | User Agreement and Privacy Policy | Rights and Permissions | Contact Us | Company | About News Room| RSS RSS Feed