LEADING NEWS SOURCE FOR TURKEY AND THE REGION

DEFENSE UPDATE > Koç’s defense business a casualty of feud with government?

Burak BEKDİL

After the warship contract, which was won by Turkey’s biggest conglomerate Koç Group and canceled by the government’s executive committee, could Koç now be deprived of the tank deal?

Print Page Send to friend »
Koç’s armored vehicles maker, Otokar, has been working to produce four prototypes for the Altay, Turkey’s first national main battle tank, under a $500 million prototype contract. DAILY NEWS photo, Emrah GÜREL

Koç’s armored vehicles maker, Otokar, has been working to produce four prototypes for the Altay, Turkey’s first national main battle tank, under a $500 million prototype contract. DAILY NEWS photo, Emrah GÜREL

It is not a secret that Turkey’s biggest industrial conglomerate, Koç Holding, has never been Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s favorite business group. Its owners are too little conservative and are often portrayed as the “Istanbul elite,” as opposed to Erdoğan’s preferred conservative businesses from the Anatolian heartland.

But facts are facts. Koç Holding owns the country’s only refinery, along with joint ventures with international carmakers Ford and Fiat and a number of other manufacturing powerhouses. The group provides 9 percent of the country’s GDP, 10 percent of its exports and 9 percent of its tax revenues.

The first major public tension between Koç and Erdoğan’s government emerged this summer. In one incident during month-long demonstrations in June, protesters tried to escape police tear gas and pepper spray by taking refuge in a posh Istanbul hotel, Divan, owned by Koç. Hotel management admitted the protesters to its lobby, which quickly turned into a makeshift first aid room.

The police fired more tear gas and pepper spray into the hotel lobby although it is illegal to fire these chemicals into indoor spaces. It was reported that Ali Koç, a board member and third generation family member, had ordered the hotel to help the protesters.

PM drops a hint to Koç 

On June 16, an angry Erdoğan said in a public rally: “We know which hotel owners helped terrorists [protesters]. It is a crime to abet terrorists. And those crimes will not remain unpunished.”

Shortly after that brawl, tax police raided Koç’s refinery subsidiary, Tüpraş. Officials said it was a regular inspection. But on Sept. 26 the government’s executive committee that oversees defense procurement scrapped a $2 billion deal with Koç’s shipyards, RMK Marine, pledging new competition.

This is a program (MILGEM) for the eventual construction of eight corvettes (corvettes are the smallest warships in the Turkish Navy). In January, RMK Marine signed the contract for six vessels.

Would the other multi-billion dollar Koç defense business with the government, this time for the production of Turkey’s first national main battle tank, the Altay, become a casualty too? 

Some defense industry sources insist that the decision over MILGEM was political. “The government crackdown is very visible here,” said one source.

But defense officials deny there is any political link here. Murad Bayar, Turkey’s top defense procurement official, told U.S. weekly Defense News that one Istanbul shipyard filed a complaint that the earlier two-way contest which RMK Marine won had violated competition rules. Bayar’s Undersecretariat for Defense Industries (SSM) had invited two companies to the MILGEM competition, RMK Marine and Dearsan, although a 2007 Strategic Sector Document issued by SSM had named seven shipyards as potential bidders in Turkish naval programs.

The timing of the probe into the contest supports Bayar’s view. The Prime Ministry’s Inspection Board found the complaint about the tender accurate and advised for the cancellation of the contract with RMK Marine in April or May, some time before the Gezi protests took off. 

“This has caused us a loss of one year in progressing with this program,” Bayar said. “Now we will invite all seven to a new competition.”

Koç’s serial production not guarantee

What about the Altay? Koç’s armored vehicles maker, Otokar, has been working hard to produce four prototypes for the Altay under a $500 million “prototype contract” but this deal does not mean the company also has a contract for the serial production worth billions of dollars. 

For Koç, things look better here. Top defense officials say that they would prefer the prototype-maker for the serial production contract “although selecting another manufacturer is technically and legally possible.” 

One source said: “Changing the producer after the prototype-maker has gained so much experience does not make sense. But we may expand the producing group and involve other partners too.” k HDN

November/12/2013

PRINTER FRIENDLY Send to friend »

READER COMMENTS

Notice on comments

altinkoza Ahmet

11/18/2013 7:20:11 PM

The problem of the turkish automotive industry is that from the beginning in the sixties they, Koc and others for the commercial vehicles did not look for the production of their own vehicles like Korea and other countries. they started with ckd, moved to partly turkish production and produce import cars with low turkish labor costs. And they the are still doing this today as RENAULT, TOYOTA and HYUNDAI and some others. And that is the main problem of the turkish automotive industry.

Eric Martin

11/17/2013 2:38:02 AM

Hey Hurriyet, how about an investigation into how the Koc's(Koch's) win their contracts.

Sultan Davut

11/14/2013 2:11:07 PM

I don't know what to tell you Eric. The CAD is allot more complicated than this. And if you think producing Fiat is the only thing in Koc's business line, ur wrong and are an example of a foreigner who has a superficial understanding of the country. And if you do know about all the others, and are choosing to ignore their contribution not only to the country's economic, but also political development, I'm guessing you would either not have much of a background in economics or are hard leftist.

Eric Martin

11/13/2013 10:03:00 PM

@Sultan. Thanking Koc's is like thanking foreigners basically. We have a CAD problem for some reason. Building foreign cars where most of the profits leave the country might be part of it. Tax breaks + Only 37% profits stay in Turkey. Whooppeee!

Sultan Davut

11/13/2013 8:31:28 AM

I can forgive our foreign friends for talking about things that they don't fully have a background on, but any Turk who says that groups like Koç, Çukurova, Sabanci, Eczacıbaşı etc. were not essential to bringing this country out of the dark ages don't know what they are talking about. Of course there were close biz/state relations. Industrial policy needs this in countries trying catch-up with the west when starting from backwardness. Without them, Turkey would look like....

dogan kemal ileri

11/13/2013 1:12:01 AM

Why would I pay taxes to Turkiye @Red Tail I am not a Turkish subject and have never lived and worked here apart from the one year I lectured at Ankara as a foreign consultant when I did pay local income taxes. But why do you compare me to a multinational conglomerate you should stay cocooned in your playpen and leave adult topics to those of us who are more adept.

Murat

11/12/2013 11:44:04 PM

How comical that haters of Koc family never make an issue of countless contracts and benefits "yandash" get from their support of AKP. Like all business they benefited from the laws that protected Turkish industries and manufactureres. How do you think all this happened, magic of AKP? Koc was here at the beginning of this republic they will be here long after Erdogan is gone.

Eric Martin

11/12/2013 10:40:14 PM

@dogan kemal ileri - The Koc's couldn't construct a building with their hands let alone a car. They are in the business of sweet talking politicians and contracting out work to others.

Eric Martin

11/12/2013 10:32:55 PM

@Mehmet. Agree. There is more to this and how contracts use to be given out. The Koc's are very cozy with generals for a reason.

sam afg alokozai

11/12/2013 10:32:51 PM

why US is opposing iran and put sanction on it, however without sanctions US can earn much from iran. the answer is simple, how US put national & its allies security at risk and leave iran to support terror? So how can Turkish Government (AKP) trust on a group, who openly support looters and rogue elements of society ...
< >

MOST POPULAR

AcerPro S.I.P.A HTML & CSS Agency