SEMİH İDİZ > Erdoğan’s Moscow visit is an opportunity

Print Page Send to friend »
Russia has effectively blocked the prospect of any early solution to the Syrian crisis as it considers itself to have been cheated over Libya and is suspicious over the intentions of the West and Turkey. 

If anything, Moscow is likely to harden its stance after U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton called for those backing the Assad regime “to pay a price,” and Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu, following in her footsteps, called for countries supporting the Syrian regime, “to be isolated.”

As matters stand, Syria is no longer a simple issue of “a brutal dictator killing innocent people.” This issue is one of the main battlegrounds of the new conflict between the East and the West. Until that conflict is resolved it is unlikely that the desired stability in Syria, and consequently the Middle East as a whole, will be attained. 

The visit that Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan is to pay Moscow on Wednesday in response to an invitation by President Vladimir Putin will take place against this backdrop. There is the possibility of cold winds blowing from both sides during talks that are expected to concentrate on Syria. 

Ankara believes Moscow is supporting a bloodthirsty dictator and his regime for the sake of strategic interests. It is not too happy that this support has left Turkey’s policy towards Syria in a mess. Davutoglu’s call for countries supporting the Syrian regime to be isolated should also be seen in this context. 

Moscow, for its part, suspects that the West’s and Turkey’s involvement in Syria is not based purely on innocent reasons. Judging by commentary in the Russian media, the feeling is that both the West and Turkey are after their own material interests in that country.

The bottom line is that Russia is clearly not prepared to give up its final stronghold in the Middle East. Neither does it want an Islamic regime supported by countries like Saudi Arabia or Qatar to emerge in place of the current regime in Damascus. 

All indications point to the idea that Moscow does not view the support by Turkey to the Syrian opposition as having humanitarian motives, but rather sees this in the context of “Sunni solidarity” aimed at bringing a “Muslim Brotherhood” type Islamist group to power. 

Historically Russia has also considered itself to be a protector of Christian minorities in the Middle East, a mission that was reanimated after the fall of the Soviet Union. There are those who argue that the common fear of Islamic fundamentalism and a desire to protect Christian minorities will eventually push Moscow and Washington to cooperating over Syria. 

That remains to be seen, of course. What is clear, however, is that a predominantly Sunni regime with and Islamic orientation, which is clearly the preference of Prime Minister Erdoğan and the Justice and Development Party (AKP), is unlikely to emerge in that country under prevailing circumstances.

It would therefore be wiser for Erdoğan and the AKP to give up on such expectations and act according to the realities on the ground. Erdoğan’s Moscow visit provides a good opportunity in this respect. 

An understanding between Turkey and Russia on Syria will not only be good for that country, but also contribute to stability in the Middle East, while also contributing to world peace. Erdoğan and Putin have enjoyed warm relations in the past, and this should help in making positive headway. 

In the meantime Foreign Minister Davutoğlu, who will accompany Erdoğan, will also get a chance to explain to his counterpart, Sergei Lavrov, what he meant when he called for the countries supporting Assad to be isolated.

This particular remark of Davutoğlu’s was also criticized by CHP leader Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu. In an interview with daily Milliyet, during which this writer was also present, Kılıçdaroğlu said mockingly that many countries who heard Davutoğlu’s words “must have laughed through their backsides.” 

In addition to this Davutoğlu, while in Moscow, can also ask for the “objective information” that Russia says it has on the Turkish jet Ankara says was downed by Syria. 

That could help enlighten the Turkish public on a subject that has turned into a political fiasco for the AKP. 

The hope is that the opportunity provided by this visit will be availed of fully.


PRINTER FRIENDLY Send to friend »


Notice on comments

B Medic

7/19/2012 11:18:06 PM

@Blue, Your imagination is really impressive. I thought oil was the main reason for US interest in ME, not making life miserable for Christians. If Syrian Christians were so happy with Al-Assad, then how come millions of them have left the country during the Al-Assad family's reign? If you believe US is planning to create a Kurdish state in SE Turkey, I rest my case.

Blue Dotterel

7/19/2012 5:40:43 PM

US foreign policy is predicated on the ethnic cleansing of miniorities' not only in Iraq but throughout the ME. Even in Syria, the Christian population in Homs has been attacked by the NATO backed terrorists. The Christians in Syria rely on the Assad gov't for protection. The same will occur in Turkey when the US shifts its sights to creating a Kurdish state in the SE. The Syriacs have nothing to look forward to.

B Medic

7/18/2012 12:08:22 PM

@Blue, US has not supported any ethnic cleansing of Christians in Iraq, that is nonsense and you know it (As if you would care for any Christians. You only like to say nasty things about US and Israel). Any external support for FSA is not more disgusting than the support Syria and your beloved home country Iran has been giving to the Hizbollah terrorists and gangsters in Lebanon over the years.

Blue Dotterel

7/17/2012 9:04:24 PM

The US (and Israel) want chaos or a US backed regime in Syria (preferably Muslim Brotherhood). The US contributed to the ethnic cleansing of Christians from Iraq, and will do the same in Syria. Nato and GCC fueling the violence in Syria by financing and arming the mercenaries there is nothing short of disgusting.

ilker avni

7/17/2012 8:37:30 PM

Trade is a big factor in Turkeys relations with Russia,allso Azerbajan problem with Armenia,these are all problems that has to be dealt with between Russia and Turkey.Turkeys postion as a major energy hub is a problem for Russia.Russia needs Turkey more than Turkey needs Russia.With both beniifitting from growing trade.Russia has more to lose than Turkey.Russia will have to dance to Turkeys tune.

B Medic

7/17/2012 11:32:52 AM

@Deniz. If US and its allies had wanted a full-blown war in Syria, there would be one already. But the conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan both became much longer, bloodier and more expensive than predicted. The consequences of attacking Syria are even harder to predict with all its internal ethnic and other conflicts. The question is how to get rid of the dreadful Al-Assad without too much blood.

Deniz Can

7/17/2012 6:04:49 AM

It seems that power of media of Neo-liberal political system under the leading power of US has already influenced everyone even BBC. All scenarios are being built on the war to get ride of Assad, without considering the cost of even a regional ethnic conflict. Even Mr. IDIZ is not speaking about the Annan's plan. The conflict between two different ethnicities has already been created. Departure of Assad through a war is not anymore a solution without agreeing on a collective transitional power.

dogan kemal ileri

7/17/2012 2:22:40 AM

The stance of the Russians and the Chineese on the Syrian issue is nothing short of disgusting.Those two counntries are responsible for the deaths of thousands of innocent civilians which include children.Assad is cock a hoop at the political support he is getting and emboldened to keep killing at ever incresing rates.Hiliary Clinton got it right when she boldy stated they would pay for their actions of nurturing a paranoic dictator killer like Assad and his Baathist party+UN action is a joketoo


7/17/2012 12:45:23 AM

The key to the Syrian crisis is an understanding between Russia and Turkey. There is a middle road that would make all content if not happy and that is where real diplomacy is needed.
< >


AcerPro S.I.P.A HTML & CSS Agency