BARÇIN YİNANÇ > Do Arabs want Turkey to lead the Arab awakening?

Print Page Send to friend »
Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoğlu’s speech in Parliament last week was definitely one of the two most ambitious policy statements to have come from Turkey in the post-Cold War era, along with that of the country’s former President Turgut Özal.

Let’s recall what Davutoğlu said: “We will manage the wave of change in the Middle East. Just as the ideal we have in our minds about Turkey, we have an ideal of a new Middle East. We will be the leader and the spokesperson of a new peaceful order, no matter what they say.”

Let’s recall what Özal said following the fall of iron curtain, which led to the birth of Turkic states in Central Asia, as well as states in Eastern Europe where Turkish minorities found a better chance to be recognized. 
“There is a Turkish world lying from the Adriatic Sea to the Great Wall of China. If we don’t make serious mistakes, the 21st century could be the century of Turks and Turkey.” 

If we contrast Özal’s cautiousness reflected in his expression “If we don’t make serious mistakes,” to Davutoğlu’s “No matter what they say” - implying that Turkey will do as it plans, whether it is welcomed or not - it would be fair to say that the foreign minister’s speech is unrivalled for forcing the limits of arrogance. 

It was not exactly clear whom he had in mind when he said, “No matter what they say.” Did he mean the Turkish opposition? Did he mean international or regional players? Actually, what he thought matters less than how it is perceived in the Arab world. 

I am extremely curious whether all in the Arab world welcome Turkey’s leadership of the wave of change in the region.

Davutoğlu seems to have no doubt, since he said, “I’d like to advise those who are criticizing us: Go to Cairo. Go to Tripoli. Go to the streets of Beirut, Tunisia, Jerusalem, and ask about Turkey’s policy on Syria. They will hug you and express their appreciation for Turkey’s honorable policy.”

Speaking after Davutoğlu in Parliament, opposition People’s Republican Party’ or CHP’s deputy Osman Korutürk was just back from Cairo. He talked about the forth meeting between Turkish and Arab parliamentarians last week in Cairo, and expressed doubt about the accuracy of Minister Davutoğlu’s statement. If Davutoğlu is right, then why did taken hours for Turkish and Arab MPs to agree on a joint statement? It seems that when the Arab deputies expressed their wish to include a sentence stipulating that no foreign army should enter Syria met the objection of Justice and Development Party (AKP) deputies, it took hours to agree on a statement.

Davutoğlu’s speech, which carries the unfortunate risk of being perceived as patronizing, reminded me of Turkey’s euphoria in the early 1990s about Central Asia. It took some time for Turkey to realize that having recently gotten rid of a big brother like Russia, the newly independent Turkic countries were not looking for another brother.

I am afraid that with this kind of romanticism and over-ambition, Davutoğlu will remain blind to the possibility that not all Arabs are willing to see Turkey administering the change and shaping the vision of the Middle East.

With Davutoğlu’s rhetoric, who can blame those criticizing Turkey for neo-Ottomanism?


PRINTER FRIENDLY Send to friend »


Notice on comments

Memduh Cevdet

5/1/2012 9:59:44 PM

Neo-Ottoman rhetoric should be replaced with pragmatic messages and increased cooperation. Patronizing comments will only fuel anti-Turkish sentiments amongst advesarial groups.

Tomas Giovanni

5/1/2012 9:32:52 PM

Does anyone believe TR has been forgiven by the Arab nations for something that happened during the Ottoman empire?

Red Tail

5/1/2012 7:04:56 PM

Our PM and FM are popular in Middle East. But that does not mean that their people want to be taken over or controlled by Turkey. They are simply different things.

Blue Dotterel

5/1/2012 9:20:39 AM

Davutoglu dropped the ball when he betrayed the people of Libya and Syria in favor of supporting the West and Israel's aggressive policy against these people's independence. The Arab people know who the AKP are working for.

sam stevens

5/1/2012 9:11:40 AM

Good article. Power seems to have gone to Mr D's head, his arrogance is breathtaking, I believe , it is this 'fault' which will be the man's undoing.

Another View

5/1/2012 7:04:00 AM

Davudoglou's arrogance is only matched by Erdpgan's. Beware of their hubris

Kevin Snapp

5/1/2012 6:48:25 AM

For a nation's foreign minister, and an educated and cultured man, the lack of tact and diplomacy shown by FM Davutoğlu is surprising.

belal zakaria

5/1/2012 6:03:37 AM

I think it is beyond the ability of the west east north or south to think ,how to put world on their feet with trade jobs income (instantly).My 60 yrs exp tells me they are just capable to pick up little hint,pick up a tiny clue develop themselves?

dogan kemal ileri

5/1/2012 1:28:35 AM

Turkiye's foreign policy have been too insular and too apologetic and too servile to western interests but sice Erdogan took office and appointed Davutoglu as Foreign Secretary our foreign relations,trade and influence have rocketed.We are proud
< >


AcerPro S.I.P.A HTML & CSS Agency