NURAY MERT > Dark country

Print Page Send to friend »
What is happening in Turkey nowadays reminds me of Mark Mazower’s brilliant revision of 20th century European history (“Dark Continent,” 1999), a “frightening reminder of how fragile democracy has been” according to fellow-historian Orlando Figes in The Times.

The beginning of the 20th century in Europe was a time of crises after the dissolution of the old order, but the idea of democracy was a short-lived experience that soon led to the rise of authoritarianism across the continent. The dissolution of the Ottoman Empire can be viewed as a somewhat similar experience.

The history of democracy has been a long search for reconciling the idea of freedoms and political stability. Europe paid a high price to achieve this difficult combination, and Turkey is still struggling to reach a compromise between the two principles. Throughout the history of modern Turkey, every attempt to build a democratic politics is hindered by sliding back to authoritarian politics in the search for political stability. In fact, it was never the whim of the military establishment that interrupted the process of democratization, as is widely believed nowadays. Instead, the main obstacle in the path of democratization has always been the search for an easy option to overcome the uncertainties and turmoil of democratic politics, as was the case in the rise of a variety of authoritarian rules that arose in Europe between the two world wars.

The democrats of Turkey are confused by the rise of authoritarian politics through the ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) only because they missed this point and simply defined the rise of civilian political power at expense of the diminishing power of the military as the necessary rise of democratic politics. The current authoritarian politics are simply about sacrificing freedoms in search of political stability and tranquility. Rises in authoritarianism have always been instances of “collective political guilt” after all, as we human beings are always inclined to opt for easy ways to avoid uncertainty.

Nevertheless, we always pay high prices for opting for the minimum prices, as well as for expecting maximum gains in political as well as in private lives. Now, in Turkey, we witness the rise of authoritarian limitations to all sorts of freedoms - from the soap operas that we choose to watch to all kinds of political freedoms. Moreover, the sacrificing of freedoms has neither provided stability nor certainty and tranquility, since we have ended up with the utmost instability resulting from social polarization and domestic tension, as well as the uncertainties of a volatile foreign policy.

The price of avoiding uncertainty and tension has only been more uncertainty and tension, minus freedoms. Turkey is a dark country now and it may pay higher prices unless we recognize the further dangers of authoritarian politics.


PRINTER FRIENDLY Send to friend »


Notice on comments

Deniz Can

12/10/2012 1:15:05 PM

PART1 History showed that religions have always claimed political power. In the case of Europe, religion lost this power through the Renascence. In the case of Islam, the process hasn’t completed yet. I believe this is one of the main reasons for authoritarian systems in Islamic countries. The Republic experienced an authoritarian system for the suppression of other nationalities and religion freedom for the sake of Turkish nationalism

Deniz Can

12/10/2012 1:14:46 PM

PART2 on the other hand, the AKP has been experiencing a multi-dimensional authoritarian system for the strengthening of Turkish nationalism and Sunni based religion culture. Therefore the AKP doesn’t hesitate in interfering in every aspect of social and political life. A real democracy is not the priority. Religion gained opportunity in Arab countries through ‘Arab Spring’ using the same methods. This will continue until the religion has lost its claim of political power like in Europe

Ryan James

12/10/2012 7:29:53 AM

"Collective political guilt" what nonsense! So the people are responsible for The current Turkish fascism? Bizarre reasoning.

mara mcglothin

12/10/2012 2:45:00 AM

Lets all hope it isn't too late, and you shouldn't have written this piece a year ago.

Hasan Kutlay

12/10/2012 1:11:13 AM

Good article

Kerem Kemal

12/10/2012 12:33:14 AM

Dear Nuray Hanim, I think you are too pessimistic. It has become a little darker in Turkey, but there are still burning enough lights, you should not underestimate the abilities of our people!
< >


AcerPro S.I.P.A HTML & CSS Agency