SEMİH İDİZ > Both sides are losers in Cyprus

Print Page Send to friend »
Mehmet Özay, Professor Emeritus of International Affairs and Economics at Carleton University in Ottawa, has a dream. In a piece penned for the Cyprus Mail on Sunday, Özay writes “Imagine a united Cyprus at the centre of a region of cooperation involving energy, water, tourism, higher education.”

He adds, “A reunited Cyprus would be an economic magnet: billions would come flowing in to develop and market offshore gas, shipped to markets in the West via Turkish pipelines. Plentiful water supplies from Anamur in southern Turkey would start reaching the island, with electricity not far behind. On offer are economies of scale, lower costs and more competitiveness.”

But Özay, who lists other advantages that would follow a settlement, also gives the reason why his dream will not be realized. “Of course, all this assumes rational behavior by all Cypriots in order to optimize their own interests,” he says, adding, “Recent history is sadly not on the side of rationality” when it comes to the Cyprus problem.

Had rationality been part of the equation, this problem, with half a century behind it, would have been long resolved. The fact is that the sides, even when appearing close to an agreement - as was the case with the negotiations leading up to the failed Annan Plan of 2003 – have always talked at cross purposes.

Greek Cypriots, in the final analysis, never had a genuine intention to share power on an equal footing with their Turkish counterparts – as admitted to in so many words by the late President Tassos Papadopoulos in a teary eyed television address just prior to the 2004 referendum on the Annan Plan.

On the Turkish side, it was clear all along from the intransigence of the late President Rauf Denktaş – who also had his teary eyed moment prior to the 2004 referendum on the Annan Plan – that what was being aimed at was independence for the North under Turkey’s protection – or a settlement with the South that would amount to that.

Meanwhile, having scuttled the Annan Plan in the April 2004 referendum, Greek Cyprus was still awarded with EU membership, which clearly took away any incentive to solve the problem, and which many in Europe are overtly or covertly admitting today was a big mistake.

Greek Cypriots, however, clearly expected EU membership to provide them with serious leverage against a Turkey, which was mistakenly believed to be prepared to give all sorts of concessions for the sake of its own EU membership bid. Likewise, the Greek Cypriot term presidency of the EU in the second half of 2012 was expected to provide a tool for sweet and sour pressure against Ankara.

That failed to work too, since Turkey simply pressed the off switch in its ties with the EU Council for the six months of the Greek Cypriot presidency. Meanwhile, matters started going seriously awry for the Greek Cypriots, who are today facing a devastating economic crisis from which economists say it will take a decade to emerge.

This has clearly pushed the Cyprus problem onto the back burner for the average Greek Cypriot, who has more immediate matters to consider nowadays. Meanwhile, while trying to reinstate their sovereignty over the whole Island, Greek Cypriots will now discover what loss of economic, and hence political, sovereignty to international organizations will mean - the way Greece has.

The situation for Turkish Cypriots, however, is not much brighter. Turkish Cyprus is today totally dependent on handouts from Turkey due to international embargoes on it prompted by the Greek Cypriot side. It is also in a state of economic turmoil, with unions up in arms and the average person on the street complaining about his or her worsening lot.

Turkey’s current economic strength will, of course, act as a buffer against total collapse in the North of Cyprus. The corollary, however, is that Northern Cyprus is becoming less independent and more dependent on Turkey as time goes by. Tellingly, the number of mainland Turks in the North today outnumbers the number of Turkish Cypriots, and there is little love lost between the sides.

Many Turkish Cypriots feel they have been colonized by Turkey and are openly saying so, much to the chagrin of nationalist Turks on the Island and the mainland. Expecting to preserve their own cultural identity against Greek Cypriots, Turkish Cypriots feel they are loosing their identity to Turkey, whose province they clearly do not want to become.

In the final analysis, it is clear that it will be the Turkish Cypriots who are the real losers in this whole equation. Whether Greek Cypriots will be able to argue that they are the winners, however, is a wide open question.


PRINTER FRIENDLY Send to friend »


Notice on comments

Peter Panayiotou

2/4/2013 6:27:31 AM

Mr Albay the fact is that the blame for Cyprus can be put squarly on the shoulders of both the mother countries who have done their best to take over Cyprus one way or the other. There is no respect for the Cypriot nationality as a whole and that is the root of the problem. As for the allegation of disrespect of the TCs - thats not true. The GCs disrespect the undemocratic idea that 4 GCs are equivalent to one TC when it comes to government.How can one respect people who propose this??

john albay

2/3/2013 12:55:46 PM

The puppet state let of greek occupied cyprus is Bankrupt,it has spent the money of the russian,serbian and bulgarian mafias and now want the EU taxpayer to bail them out! As for pawel bury you have zero idea what you are talking about! The evil greek cypriots started this mess, lied to the world and started an inhuman embargo against Turkish cypriots,they have no respect for us Turkish cypriots and only want a 100% greek run island. We will never forgive EOKA B or the murderer sampson!

Peter Panayiotou

1/26/2013 4:48:00 PM

I am confused. Where are all these Greek settlers in Cyprus that the Turks commenting seem to think have arrived on the island?I dont recall meeting ONE mainland Greek when I last visited Cyprus.! Can the TCs say the same of the Turkish settlers?? I doubt it for the simple reason that there are, it is said, now more Turks in the North than TCs as a result of determined policy to change the ethnicity of the north.


1/15/2013 5:57:19 AM

There is this talk of settlers going back. I am curious, do you mean only Turkish settlers? How about Greek settlers, and I mean going back all the way to 1878. When and wehre will they go? There are only TC on Cyprus now, after a half century, there are no more settlers. Congratulations! How would Greeks pay for the economic losses they inflicted on TCs by the way and the accumulated share of all they received? Are you sure it is wise to unite the way you guys envision?

Adam Polk

1/13/2013 12:45:01 PM

Pawel Bury, mad? funny... look how many comment you posted, and how many I did under this piece... seems you are pretty mad, keep posting same stuff over and over again. then attack people who doesn't think like you.

Pawel Bury

1/13/2013 12:12:01 PM

It seems in Turkey truth is mud. Otherwise you wouldn't get so mad...

Nikos T.

1/13/2013 11:28:29 AM

Dear Gercek, You are a kind very person with goodwill. Being in a Turkish forum I everyday read how vicious, liars and evil Greeks are. Take a look at the posts on this thread. The lack of arguments brings insulting comments. I'd be glad if you tried to pass some of your goodwill to this confused people. Passing away goodwill is way more productive than passing insults or paid hatred. Goodwill is what TCs and GCs have. Anybody who talks with them can understand this.

Adam Polk

1/13/2013 11:22:10 AM

Chris Green, "mud" is what Greeks use best now. just keep doing what you do, it seems you are on the right path.

Chris Green

1/13/2013 11:06:21 AM

If my 'hobby' is pointing out Greek 'mistakes', it seems unlikely that I shall ever be idle nor bored of it! I shall certainly never tire of taking the Turkish & Turkish Cypriot line and broadcasting same around the world. I am taking issue with the Hellim problem this week whilst watching these threads with interest and amusement. Freezing cold over here; toasting the Greek side is self-warming:-) Happy Sunday, all!

Dennis Kavaz

1/13/2013 5:22:28 AM

The two Cypriots may have resemblance (but the two have an count to settle) if G Cyprus have the extra cash “from gas” they (GCs) would firstly buy the beast of weapons, secondly, they would employ mercenaries to teach them to fight; and thirdly (because Turkey stopped them in 1974 for taking all Cyprus) They (G Cs) have an count to settle with their fellow T Cypriots and more-so with Turkey. Yeah hatred and revenge has been in Greeks gene since genesis.
< >


AcerPro S.I.P.A HTML & CSS Agency