LEADING NEWS SOURCE FOR TURKEY AND THE REGION

INTERNATIONAL > Armenia fosters ‘genocide’ campaigns in France, Israel

ISTANBUL - Hürriyet Daily News

Armenia pushes support for its genocide claims in recent actions in Israel and France as the 100th anniversary of the 1915 killings nears. The developments are a sign ofTurkish foreign policy's failure, says a retired envoy.

French President Nicolas Sarkozy (C) and his Armenian counterpart Serge Sarkisyan light candles in the Etchmiadzine Patriarcat Cathedral after a meeting with Armenian patriarche Karekine II in Erevan on October 6, 2011. AFP photo

French President Nicolas Sarkozy (C) and his Armenian counterpart Serge Sarkisyan light candles in the Etchmiadzine Patriarcat Cathedral after a meeting with Armenian patriarche Karekine II in Erevan on October 6, 2011. AFP photo

Sevim Songün Demirezen Sevim Songün Demirezen sevim.songun@hurriyet.com.tr

Armenia has sped up its efforts to promote its genocide claims ahead of the 100th anniversary of the 1915 killings of Armenians, with actions in two countries – France and Israel – whose relations with Turkey have deteriorated over the past few years.

The Armenian Genocide Museum-Institute in Yerevan and the Yad Vashem Holocaust Museum in Jerusalem will establish cooperation in many areas, according to an Israeli minister. Reports from France also claim that newly issued history textbooks contain Armenian genocide claims, a move likely to further strain already tense relations with Ankara.

“I offered the Genocide Museum-Institute administration to cooperate with Yad Vashem Holocaust Museum in Jerusalem,” Israeli Minister of Information and Diaspora Yuli Edelstein was quoted as saying by the Panarmenian news website. “Both our nations have been victims of horrible crimes against humanity. I think the two institutions would cooperate quite effectively in terms of the selection of exhibits and the organization of pavilions,” Edelstein said Aug. 24 during a visit to Yerevan.

Although Israel does not officially recognize the alleged Armenian genocide, Edelstein wrote the following in the visitor’s book at the genocide museum in Yerevan: “Nobody in Israel denies the fact of Armenian Genocide.”

Süha Umar, a retired Turkish ambassador, told the Daily News that the two developments were a sign of the failures of Turkish foreign policy, caused by perceived Turkish weaknesses on the issue.

‘Redundant’ details in French textbooks
Turkey’s relations with Israel are tense, since Israeli commandos killed nine pro-Palestinian Turkish activists on May 2010 in a raid on the Mavi Marmara flotilla, which aimed to stop the embargo on Gaza.
 
Cultural cooperation between Armenia and Israel is not surprising at a time when Turkey’s relations with Israel have come to the zero point, Turkish columnist Semih İdiz told the Hürriyet Daily News yesterday.

France, where a recent bill penalizing the denial of Armenian “genocide” was annulled by the French Constitutional Council, will start to teach Armenian genocide allegations to secondary students.

History-Geography Teachers Council Secretary General Hubert Tison said the chapter in the new French textbooks gives “redundant” detailed information on the issue, according to daily Hürriyet. Turkish Education Ministry officials say they will respond in line with international law through diplomatic channels. İdiz, a columnist for Turkish daily Milliyet and also for the Daily News, said the concept of that the Armenians suffered a genocide was part of French society, and also said further campaigns would continue until 2015. French President François Hollande has vowed to introduce a new bill penalizing denial of the Armenian genocide.

Hollande’s approval declines

PARIS - Reuters

French President François Hollande’s approval rating fell to 54 percent in August, continuing a steady decline since he came to office, according to a poll released on Aug. 25. The poll, by Ifop for Le Journal du Dimanche newspaper, marked a slide from 61 percent who were satisfied or very satisfied with Hollande’s performance in May, the month he became president, to 59 percent in June and 56 percent in July. The declining ratings reflect the challenges Hollande faces in tackling high unemployment and a stagnant economy.


August/27/2012

Send to friend »

READER COMMENTS

Click for Hürriyet Daily News comment guidelines

Hairenakitz Hirenakitz

9/5/2012 2:49:17 AM

I am excited to see that finally Turkish students in France can read their ancestoral history. Sooner or later enen in Turkey public has to know the truth missing from their own history books.

Murat

8/27/2012 9:46:16 PM

Wow American, why dont you tell us how you really feel about Turks?

Murat

8/27/2012 9:44:58 PM

I am all for all embaressing and shamefull acts Republic has committed to be aired and exposed and restitutions made. God knows there is plenty there. But to come clean for an alleged genocide that never took place and for events that may have happend more than century ago in an empire that is now buried in history? I draw the line there. Armenians have already assasinated all those who they thought repsonible and the rest were made to give account in courts. Who will pay for Armenian sins?

Erik Johansson

8/27/2012 8:22:39 PM

Honesty is a sign of strenght and maturity and Turkey needs to grow up. It is time to deal with nearly 100 years of silence, denial and relativization in this matter.

Red Tail

8/27/2012 5:32:23 PM

Not being very nationalistic, I find this discussion about "being a shamed or proud of my country's history" rather strange. Firstly, I do not need a nation or its history to make me feel lika good and valuable person. I feel proud and happy for what I am, how I act and for what I do for other people, not for my nationality. I also feel a shame or sad for MY wrong doings, not my country's 100 years ago. Only confused people mix their individual with national identity.

V Tiger

8/27/2012 5:26:47 PM

Why does Turkey deny the Genocide committed by the Ottomans & Young Turks?Why do they feel frightened in accepting & apologizing the truth?The Armenians do not blame the current Turks & Turkey for committing Genocide.But Turkey being the inheritor of Ottomans & Young Turks has moral obligation to face the truth & restore & compensate the Armenians of what they've lost.

Murat

8/27/2012 5:01:17 PM

This is not the first or last time textbooks have been used to spread falsehoods and propaganda, ask Russians, Chinese and yes, Nazis. Facts remain meanwhile as facts. French who have not come clean on their bloody past around the globe, and who have unleashed the Legion Armenique on the beaten and devestated Turkish nation have little to say here. There was no genocide or millions of hateful Armenians would not be around now.

Adam Polk

8/27/2012 3:15:22 PM

american american, Red Tail, guys did I say anything about Turkish textbooks? I am just saying, being judged by french is little awkward. Red Tail, I am not representing any nationality or ideology. why do you have to make it "adam thinks that, it means all turks think that" Gil Mihaely, I wish this historical event judged by those french people you are talking about. unfortunately corrupt positional on the stage.

american american

8/27/2012 2:56:40 PM

adam, for the sake of argument - can we say that turks didn't learn their history, either, and that if they did they, would be disgusted with their past (as a colonizing empire), be ashamed of their forefathers, and hate their current politicians? which doesn't seem to be the case very often....

Gil Mihaely

8/27/2012 2:56:33 PM

@Adam Polk : Actually many Frenc do feel ashamed of their past, a sentiement that poses a huge problem today because it makes a commun projet extremelly difficult to consolidate. Chapters like the Vichy regime, the war in Indochina, the war in Algeria, colonialisme in Asia and Africa and slave trade makes acommun history almsot impossible today. the result is that French identity and sens of belonging is weakening and the European project is unable to replace it.
< >

WRITE COMMENT

MOST POPULAR

AcerPro S.I.P.A HTML & CSS Agency