BURAK BEKDİL > ‘A great Islamic democracy’

Print Page Send to friend »
According to the EU minister, Egemen Bağış, “it is indisputable that Turkey is now closer than ever to EU standards in terms of democracy, human rights and economic developments.” According to the foreign minister, Ahmet Davutoğlu, “Turkey is not a second-class democracy” – against which this columnist once wrote that Turkey must walk a long way and reform its crippled electoral democracy to earn that title.

According to the Economist Intelligence Unit, Turkey is a hybrid regime, a ranking that comes below “flawed” democracy. But in an interview with the Italian daily Corriera della Sera in 2010, President Barack Obama referred to Turkey as “a great Islamic democracy.” 

Why did/does Mr. Obama not refer to his own country, or to his western European allies as “great Christian democracies?” Or why did he not refer to Turkey simply as “a democracy?” Why did democracy come with a religious prefix in Turkey’s case? Events after the Obama interview have powerfully illustrated that the president’s wording was not arbitrary.

In a speech during the weekend, the popular, elected leader of the great Islamic democracy once again roared about what he understands about democracy, “Whatever my nation wants, whatever direction it wishes… shall be implemented.” That is the heart of the matter with “a great Islamic democracy.” 

Now, to test the merits of his great Islamic democracy, Mr. Erdoğan can put to referendum a number of subjects: Should Abdullah Öcalan, leader of the PKK, be hanged? Should Turkey invade the rest of Cyprus? Should the government abolish the income tax? Should the price of gasoline be reduced by 80 percent? Salaries be doubled? Non-Muslim Turks be expelled and their properties confiscated to be distributed to Muslim Turks? Apostates be jailed?

In fact, “whatever my nation wishes…” is a populist politician’s nicely-wrapped wording for the great Islamic democracy which a prominent Islamic intellectual described in his column recently. Hayrettin Karaman, a professor of theology and a columnist for the pro-government Yeni Şafak, wrote that, “The governments cannot protect, through law and order, any behavior the majority would dislike or view as harmful, illegitimate and ugly. The minority will have to give up some freedoms (disapproved of by the majority). The remedy… is democracy with a reference to Islam. Otherwise, the majority, whose values could be violated by the minority, will have a right to apply the neighborhood pressure [on the minority] (“Ignoring the majority,” Hayrettin Karaman, Yeni Şafak, Nov. 8, 2013).”

This seriously problematic understanding of democracy is perfectly legitimate for Mr. Erdoğan, as evidenced by his governance regarding issues that most Muslim Turks would probably view as “ugly, harmful and illegitimate,” like alcohol, dissent, opposite-sex dating, co-ed housing and even rock music. 

But who, how and with what authority will decide what does and what does not look “ugly, harmful or illegitimate” for the majority? Ten referenda every week? And where is the pluralism and diversity that makes a democracy a democracy? But that’s precisely what separates a democracy from an Islamic democracy or, as in Mr. Karaman’s wording, “a democracy with a reference to Islam.” 

Turkey is a great Islamic democracy; not a great democracy or even a democracy. And it is a “great” Islamic democracy, not just because Mr. Obama opted for his usual euphemism when dealing with the Middle East, but because that adjective denotes Turkey’s better democratic credentials than all of the Muslim countries in its region.

There is one problem, though, about the present state of Turkey’s great Islamic democracy, a major fault that may have prompted Mr. Karaman to complain about the minority’s “ugly, harmful and illegitimate” behavior. It is still too little Islamic, or too secular with millions of drinkers, protestors and crumbs of law.

For instance, in Mssrs. Erdoğan and Karaman’s Islamic democracy, journalist/lawmaker Mustafa Balbay could have been hanged by popular vote because of his “ugly, harmful and illegitimate behavior.”
Luckily, in the ¾ pious and ¼ secular Turkey, Mr. Balbay is –temporarily- free and will be paid compensation of $1.40 for each day he spent in prison because the Constitutional Court ruled that his lengthy imprisonment amounted to a violation of the law and of his right to be elected.


PRINTER FRIENDLY Send to friend »


Notice on comments

Oz_man .

12/13/2013 4:00:56 AM

Rorschach I think I've already stated this before I don't support government funding of religious activities. Religion is an institution itself it should be run like an non-profit NGO. However this is not the argument put forward by Mr Bekdil. He is confusing what Obama has labelled Turkey as an Islamic democracy. Obama is labelling from a Western/American viewpoint. There is nothing sinister or derogatory about it. However Mr Bekdil has a problem.

Rorschach ~

12/12/2013 11:41:56 PM

Shah - Countries which base their government systems on religious beliefs are much more "Big Brother-ish" than those which are truly secular. Ever been to Saudi Arabia? Seen the "religious Police" imposing 'justice' on passers-by (to include non-muslim tourists) for not adhering to the Islamic belief system? Double-plus un-good.

Rorschach ~

12/12/2013 11:32:40 PM

Ozzie - a secular "administration" does not use taxpayer's money to fund a Ministry of Religious Affairs with billions of dollars every year to build and maintain mosques (utilities as well as salleries) . In a truly secular government, religious activities are funded directly by the individual worshippers via donations. Turkey is not a secular nation by any stretch of the definition.

alkan alkan

12/12/2013 3:46:49 PM

Islam and Democracy are mutually exclusive. For an demo just look at the world map. If you have eyes to see and brains to understand it is all there staring at you !

Engin Atik

12/12/2013 10:44:38 AM

Great article Mr. Bekdil! "Islamic Democracy" is of course a euphemism for a government form that gets its support from herd-like mass mentality. It has a closer kinship to twentieth century totalitarian regimes than to democracy.

Harry Foundalis

12/12/2013 10:39:43 AM

Murun, you wrote: “all religion is abject nonsense from start to finish.” Allow me to improve on that a bit: religion is the human beings’ effort to (a) overcome the fear of death, (b) explain and make sense of their hostile environment, (c) provide a cohesive link to societies, and (d) (perhaps most important) codify the moral rules that have their roots in our evolved biological ancestry. In (d), some religions such as Islam went way off target, moralizing on how to drink, eat, and [censored].


12/12/2013 1:39:26 AM

@Shah i did not brag about anything, i just pointed out that all religions (not just Islam) should not interfere with government in a real democracy.Having visited many islamic countries myself, i think that islamic societies cannot be democratically governed,because of the various religious restrictions imposed on them (especially on women). But that is my personal view.

a shah

12/11/2013 11:34:01 PM

Nikos you should read George Orwell (Blair) book on Orwellian democracy , you will cease bragging about your western democracy which fits well with Orwell,s predictions, yet better than what was perpetrated by Greek orthodox(Byzantines) and other churches where no personal freedom ever existed.

dogan kemal ileri

12/11/2013 9:30:59 PM

What on earth are you talking about Agnes Smith. You know very well there is a democracy deficit not only in the UK but particularly in the EU. Governments in the west are renowned to have their own agendas as soon as they get into power and regularly renege on their election manifestos.Yes thehe is democracy in as much as you can vote them out but the next lot that gets in is "encore".Thats why the electorate feels disenfranchised in the UK because thye feel their voting establishes nothing

Penelope Parisis

12/11/2013 9:22:03 PM

Mr Bekdil, a wonderful, intelligent, and brilliant article! I hope other journalist in Turkey can follow your integrity in journalism!
< >


AcerPro S.I.P.A HTML & CSS Agency